THE WORLD'S LARGEST AND MOST COMPREHENSIVE SCOUTING ORGANIZATION
| 2,384 MLB PLAYERS | 15,801 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
2,384 MLB PLAYERS | 15,801 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
Create Account
Sign in Create Account
College  | Story | 5/28/2013

NCAA Field: Dissecting the decisions


The NCAA Selection Committee unveiled the Field of 64 on Monday, and as usual, there are plenty of aspects of the selections to dissect.


Let's start this thing by giving out grades for the committee:


National seeds: B-, The committee, for the most part, did a good job with the national seeds, though, the exclusion of North Carolina State was a head scratcher if you were truly going by individual merit.


Regional hosts: A-, Arkansas certainly has a legitimate gripe when it comes a host site, but the Hogs could've ended all that discussion earlier in the season when it dropped a pair of bad RPI games to Pacific and Western Illinois.


At-large berths: C+, There were only a couple of complete head scratchers in the field this go-round. For instance, Seton Hall and Campbell should've made the field, while the fact Mercer was so far down the line was a disappointment.


Overall: B+, Though the committee made a couple of bad mistakes, namely not having N.C. State as a national seed, the group actually did a good job. Also, Dennis Farrell gets some points here for being so transparent about the process. That was a definite breath of fresh air.


Tough day for Campbell


It was supposed to be one of the most historic days in Campbell University history, and certainly for the CU baseball program, as everyone including myself thought the Camels would have their name called during the NCAA Selection Show.


Shockingly, the words Campbell never scrolled across the screen. Back in Buies Creek, N.C., head coach Greg Goff, his team, and over 100 Camels fans, including the school president, got together for a Selection Monday party, fully expecting to be heading to an NCAA Regional later this week. All left the party emotionally crushed.


"I've been in this game a long time, and this is the most devastating day over. We did enough to get in, and you can't tell me some of those teams that got in deserve an opportunity over our guys," Goff said. "All they talked about at the coaches convention was how important the RPI is. We won the regular season title in the Big South, then lost the tournament title by one run. This is just a hard, hard pill to swallow.


Clayton Brown and Campbell would've been interesting to see in the NCAA field.

"It's even more disappointing to see a team [Coastal Carolina] that finished behind you in the conference standings get into the field before you," he continued. "It's just devastating, really. That's all you can say."


Campbell has one of the more intriguing stories in the country. A religious-based school nestled jut outside of Raleigh, N.C., the Camels weren't allow to play on Sundays in past campaigns, causing them to stack up weak schedules, while also only being able to play doubleheaders on Saturdays, thus limiting their options. The Camels are now allowed to play on Sundays, so Goff expects their schedule to improve in future campaigns. In the meantime, they're just going with the hand they're dealt.


"How many people in America are going to come to Buies Creek and play us in a doubleheader on a Saturday?" Goff, frustrated, said. "I called North Carolina, North Carolina State and South Carolina, wanting to play an extra game down the stretch because I knew strength of schedule was important, and it was to no avail."


Dissecting Campbell's resume, it's easy to see both sides of the coin, though, the scheduling difficulties are explained above. The Camels had an outstanding RPI of 38 with a 14-5 road record and were 9-1 in their last 10 games. However, as NCAA Selection Committee chairman stated, the Camels didn't have a good strength of schedule, sitting at No. 237 nationally.


"Campbell's record was impressive, but we really zeroed in their strength of schedule, and non-conference strength of schedule," Farrell said. "We have to rely on what's happened in the field, and if you look at Campbell's non-conference strength of schedule, it was very weak with just one game vs. RPI Top 50."


By comparison, Coastal Carolina, which finished with an RPI of 45 and lower in the Big South standings, and got in the field of 64, was 5-8 vs. RPI Top 50. Not very impressive overall, but that's 13 games against RPI Top 50 compared to one.


We have no problem with the NCAA Selection Committee pointing to strength of schedule as a reason not to put a team in, but the Camels did enough on the field, and have a legitimate reason for their schedule not being up to par.


This one time, Campbell should've gotten the benefit of the doubt.


Why Arkansas didn't host


* One of the big stories stemming from the weekend was Arkansas not being selected as an NCAA Regional host site. South Carolina and Virginia Tech, both with much higher RPIs were chosen as host sites, while the Razorbacks, who finished higher than South Carolina in the SEC, and swept the Gamecocks in Columbia, S.C., weren't chosen. We would have given the Razorbacks a host site based on the results on the field, but Farrell and the committee didn't like the Hogs' strength of schedule.


"In Arkansas' case, it really came down to non-conference strength of schedule," Farrell said. "Arkansas' non-conference strength of schedule was 291 out of 296 teams."


Though that non-conference strength of schedule is bad to say the least, the Hogs finishing third in the SEC with an 18-11 league record should've warranted a host over South Carolina. We're fine with Virginia Tech hosting out of the ACC, though. The Hokies have a high RPI, had a good season, and were sizzling hot down the stretch. Going to Blacksburg, Va., also gives the committee some versatility in terms of hosts.


North Carolina lands top national seed


* In the grand scheme of things, it doesn't really matter who earned the top overall national seed. After all, that typically leads to more headaches than anything else. But it was a little surprising to see the Tar Heels get a national seed over Vanderbilt.


The Commodores did lose the SEC tournament title game to LSU, while the Tar Heels won the ACC regular season and tournament titles. However, the Commodores didn't lose a conference series all-year long, while the Tar Heels dropped a pair of series to Georgia Tech and Virginia.


Comparing the two teams, the Dores are 15-3 vs. RPI Top 25, 24-5 vs. RPI Top 50 and 30-8 vs. RPi Top 100, while the Tar Heels were 15-7 vs. RPI Top 25, 25-8 vs. RPI Top 50 and 36-8 vs. RPI Top 100.


"We spent a great deal of time figuring out who was going to be the top overall national seed," Farrell said. "It was a close call between North Carolina and Vanderbilt, but I'm not really sure I can articulate what the determining factor was."


So, there's that.


Last team in, last team out


* One of the best things about new committee chairman Dennis Farrell was his openness and transparency to the process. He openly admitted several times the NCAA mandates many of the geographical matches we consistently see around the country. Best of all, he pointed out the teams vying for the last national seed, while also pointing out the last team in the field and last time out of the field, something previous chairmen haven't done in my 10-plus years of covering baseball.


Mercer was the last team in, Michigan State was the last team out.


Sources with knowledge of the situation said Michigan State was in the field as late as Sunday night. However, the NCAA must've had a change of heart because Mercer was in the field Monday morning when the selections were announced on ESPN.


How Mercer was even close to being out of the field, and Michigan State close to being in the field is interesting to say the least.


The Bears had a rather solid resume. Mercer has an RPI of 29, 43-16 overall record and won the Atlantic Sun regular season title, a league that ranks 17th nationally in conference RPI. Mercer also had a solid 16-8 record on the road, 2-1 mark vs. RPI Top 50 teams and strength of schedule of 152.


By comparison, Michigan State finished seventh in the Big Ten, failing to reach the conference tournament. The Spartans, though they swept Indiana on the road and finished the year with a 7-6 mark vs. RPI Top 50, along with a 144 SOS.


The two teams might be comparable from a resume standpoint, but the difference is where both clubs finished in their respective conferences. There's no doubt the Big Ten was better than usual this spring, perhaps giving fans in that part of the country reason to believe the conference is on the rise, but the Spartans finished with a 12-9 league record.


Had the committee wanted to put in another Big Ten team besides Indiana and Illinois, I would've gone with Ohio State, which had an RPI of 63, but also finished second in the Big Ten behind Indiana. Also, the Buckeyes had a very nice 11 wins vs. RPI Top 50 teams, more than Indiana, by the way.


"We had a number of teams under consideration for those last two spots, trying to compare their bodies of work," Farrell said. "When we looked at Mercer and Michigan State, we zeroed in on non-conference SOS and non-conference RPI, and in both areas, we thought Mercer had the advantage over MSU. Auburn for instance was ranked low by the advisory committee."


Tense day for SEC bubble teams


* Dennis Farrell wouldn't speculate on who all the bubble teams in the mix for the final few spots in the NCAA postseason were, but it's safe to assume Florida and Auburn were right there with Texas A&M slightly ahead of both, as evidenced by the Aggies being a No. 2 seed in the Corvallis Regional.


It was interesting to see the Aggies pop up on the television screen as a No. 2 seed. I wouldn't have the Aggies as a No. 3 seed given their resume. A&M has a 32-27 overall record, 10-21 mark vs. RPI Top 50, but finished the season winning 10 of its last 15, including a nice 2-2 run in the SEC tournament. A&M's SEC tourney win over Vanderbilt went a long way in the eyes of the committee, while the presence of athletic director Eric Hyman, as I've suggested all along would help the Aggies, certainly didn't hurt.


"Strength of schedule and A&M's wins over Florida and Vandy played significantly," Farrell said. "A&M's 10-21 record vs. RPI Top 50 didn't matter so much."


It's pretty easy to see how Florida got into the field of 64. Despite having one of their youngest teams in the O'Sullivan era, the Gators still finished the regular season and SEC tournament one game above .500 against the nation's No. 1 SOS. The Gators also recorded 14 wins vs. RPI Top 50 and 9 wins vs. RPI Top 100.


"In our eyes, Florida had the nation's No. 1 strength of schedule," Farrell said. "They had some real challenges in non-conference play."


Last but not least, there's also Auburn. The Tigers finished the regular season on a high note with series wins over Ole Miss, Arkansas and Florida, but that wasn't enough to put them over the edge in the eyes of the committee. Auburn's non-conference strength of schedule hurt, while it was 11-16 vs. RPI Top 50 and 9-10 on the road.


"Auburn was on the board until the very, very end. We had a new RPI and the committee really did a nice job of looking at what created each team's RPI," he said. "In our regional advisory rankings, Auburn was pretty low, in addition to looking at how they did against common opponents. There was definitely some concern about strength of schedule in Auburn's case."


Auburn's exclusion from the postseason had its ramifications on Monday, as Auburn University athletic director Jay Jacobs announced the dismissal of head coach John Pawlowski, who guided the program for five seasons.


Virginia Tech caught committee's attention


As the Virginia Tech Hokies stormed through the ACC tournament last week, some were concerned the committee was putting way too much value on play in league tourneys.


Well, the committee was impressed with Tech's run in the tournament, but pointed to its record against elite opponents during the regular season as the primary reason it hosted an NCAA Regional.


"I'm not real sure we used that tournament start to gauge it," Farrell said. "We did look at their record against good teams and the fact they played in the ACC title game. They did all that in a pretty tough decision."


Virginia Tech finished the regular season with two wins over UNC Wilmington (30) and series wins over Florida State (8) and Virginia (3).


Geographic considerations still very important


One of the big topics of the day was Clemson being sent to South Carolina's NCAA Regional site for the second-straight season, and the pairing of Cal State Fullerton and UCLA for a potential next-round NCAA Super Regional.


NCAA softball currently has a system in place where they rank teams 1-16 in terms of national seeds, making things where super regional series tend to be spread out better from a geographical standpoint. However, baseball continues to be seeded 1-8, and the committee recently declined the opportunity to take up the 1-16 seeding.


"Geography is something we're told to take under consideration, kind of sticking to it as a directive from the NCAA championship cabinet," Farrell said. "Historically, Clemson and South Carolina have only been paired up once in an NCAA Regional, and that was last year. During the same amount of time, Arizona State has gone to Fullerton, Miami has gone to Florida, and so on."


As for eventually going to a 1-16 national seeding, as most on the national stage would prefer, Farrell says there's still a lot of uncertainty.


"We thought, would it create more conference matchups in super regional rounds?" he said. "It might even be more of a negative because of that, and that was one of the primary concerns of the committee.


Also worth noting …


* It was a shocker the Big East didn't get three total bids to the postseason. Connecticut (automatic bid) and Louisville (at-large) were the obvious choices, but we had Seton Hall clearly in our latest projections. The Pirates didn't have to play Louisville or Pittsburgh (first and second place) in Big East play, but still put together a good overall record at 37-19, a good RPI at 39, and were 7-3 to end the season. Strength of schedule (138) and a 1-6 mark vs. RPI Top 50 were strikes against the Pirates, but they finished league play in second place, tied with Pitt. Pitt didn't make the postseason, but that wasn't a shocker with an RPI of 60. Meanwhile, Notre Dame was an intriguing team to watch on Selection Monday. The Fighting Irish finished the year with an RPI of 32, a 34-24 overall record and were 8-7 vs. RPI Top 50. However, the fact they finished eight games behind third-place South Florida in the standings doomed them.


* I was a little surprised, but happy to see UC Santa Barbara and San Francisco make the field of 64. Programs like that have gotten the shaft in past seasons, but the presence of Dennis Farrell, a West Coast representative, likely helped their case, along with good overall resumes. The Gauchos finished high in the Big West and had a 34-23 record to go with an RPI of 55, while San Francisco reached the WCC title game and had an RPI of 50 to go with a 4-6 mark vs. RPI Top 50. Both teams could give others some headaches in the postseason.


* Lastly, just a few little quirky things I didn't like about the committee selections: Central Arkansas being the No. 4 seed in Starkville, Miss. For starters, the Bears couldn't easily been a No. 3 seed with an RPI of 62 and 14-13 record. Additionally, if you remember, the Bears earned a series win against Mississippi State earlier this season. Also, how about Towson as a No. 3 seed? Yeah, we love the Tigers' story, but this is a team with an RPI of 90 to go with a strength of schedule of 93.


College | Recruiting | 12/15/2025

Recruiting Notebook: December 15

John McAdams
Article Image
Tucker Rice (27 MS) bumping up to 91; living hi-80s from real fast arm. Good SL @ 77-79 w/ depth & sold w/ intent. Loads of traits & strikes. #WWBA @PG_Uncommitted @PG_DeepSouth pic.twitter.com/DEjFqRcsIY — Perfect Game Scout (@PG_Scouting) July 6, 2025 Tucker Rice, RHP, Class of 2027 Commitment: Alabama Alabama has continued to stay red hot in the recruiting trail ever since August 1st rolled around on the calendar and have continued to stack major pieces in their ’27 class. They dip into Mississippi to land one of the premier arms and one that’s stood out on the circuit for quite some time. It’s a fast arm and the athleticism certainly shines working down the slope. The velocity has continued to tick up over the last calendar year and reached into the low-90s towards the end of the summer. He’s confident in his changeup and the breaking ball is...
High School | General | 12/19/2025

Huntington Beach HS World Series Recap

Steve Fiorindo
Article Image
MVPitcher: Duncan McLeod The uncommitted junior toed the slab in three of the four games for Team Mick, tossing 3 2/3 innings.  Zero walks, zero hits and 6 punchouts for the lefty who was used both as a starter in the series clinching game 4 and he closed out game 3 on Friday in quick fashion.  McLeod was very efficient as well, needing just 42 pitches over all his outings.  In the game 4 start, over two innings he punched out 3, with one strikeout with all of his offerings.  The mid 80’s fastball regularly played up, set up with efficient use of the secondaries, with the breaking ball 73/74 and fading change-up 72-74.   Owen Bone (2026) at it again... Solo shot in the 5th to tie things up. Back to back days with a home run for Bone. #PGHS pic.twitter.com/2JC9qETI5h — Perfect Game California (@California_PG) December 13, 2025 MV Hitter: ...
Tournaments | Story | 12/19/2025

13u Tourney All-American Team

Jheremy Brown
Article Image
What a year it was in 2025 on the national landscape at the 13u level as Perfect Game continues to expand its reach around the country, providing an even bigger schedule of events coast-to-coast which has allowed players all over show out and gain their deserved recognition. Whether in Texas for the Houston 1000 or the 13u WWBA in West Palm Beach, we saw huge, eye opening performances from the players placed below, knowing that we could EASILY build a third team and likely a fourth without much effort.  As we do every year with this exercise, it's worth pointing out the trickiness of this age group and putting the teams together with the 13u group. While the players are all members of the Class of 2030, some are younger for the grade, which allowed them to play at the 12u level where's it's a smaller field, shorter mound distance and different bats, so we'll separate them out and...
Tournaments | Story | 12/18/2025

14u Tourney All-American Team

Tyler Russo
Article Image
Player of the Year: Asher Williams It was an incredible year for Williams that was rewarded with a trip to the 14U Select Fest, before some more impressive play in the fall. He came to the plate almost 250 times in PG tournaments throughout 2025 and reached base in well over half of them, hitting to a .500 AVG while slugging a 14U circuit best 12 bombs and driving in 113 runs. The numbers on the surface are ridiculous, but when you look at the high-level events he put them up in, it makes it even more impressive. Pitcher of the Year: Tristan Blalock Blalock earns this honor after a dominant 2025 where he struck out 85 batters in just 48.2 innings of work with a minuscule 1.58 ERA. This included several strong performances at many national level tournaments and showcases where he was able to bully some of the best hitters in the country. It’s hard not to fall in love with...
Draft | Story | 12/18/2025

PG Draft: Gut Feel Guys

Tyler Henninger
Article Image
While we are nearing the turn of the calendar to the 2026 year, that means we are just inching closer to the beginning of the season for many high school players and college baseball is on the horizon. We are prepping for a reshuffle of the 2026 MLB Draft Board as well here amongst the PG Draft staff. But before we get to that, we sat down and have each picked a couple of players who are in the mix to get selected in a couple of different buckets.  We have prospects who could go into the Top 30 picks or so, prospects who could be selected in the Top 5 rounds, and prospects who could go inside of the Top 10 rounds. With the draft quite far down the road and a lot of re-shuffling to be done as these players play themselves into certain spots on the draft board, our scouts picked some players who fit into these “buckets” who are gut-feel guys. These are the guys that our PG...
Tournaments | Story | 12/17/2025

15u Tourney All-American Team

Jason Phillips
Article Image
Hitter of the Year: Landon Bonner The 2028 class saw many players from across the country take the next step in their development as they entered the High School ranks. There were huge performances from highly ranked players on the PG circuit as well as some under-the-radar guys who burst onto the scene. Landon Bonner came into Sophomore National as a Top 500 ranked player and after an impressive showing, left with all eyes on him as a rankings riser in the class. The left-handed hitting shortstop from The Colony, Texas, had a summer to remember with All-Tournament Team selections in three of his next four events culminating with a historic performance at the 2025 PG 15U WWBA National Championship. The Hebron High School prep went 20-for-24 in nine games for 5 Star Mafia 15U Black with four homeruns and 12 runs batted in. He also scored 17 runs and finished with a mind-boggling 2.500...
Tournaments | Story | 12/16/2025

16u Tourney All-American Team

AJ Denny
Article Image
Hitter of the Year: Koa Romero is the Hitter of the Year for the 16u group, as he would come to every premier event of the summer and earn All-Tournament honors (Beast of the East, 16/17u WWBA, Jupiter) in every single one. Over 82 plate appearances, Romero would pump ten homeruns with forty two RBI and sixteen walks, good for a .378 average and 1.339 OPS. The performance on volume at the best events of the year pushed Romero over the edge here, as he’d hit a pair of homeruns in Jupiter (one of them at 112 EV) as an underclassmen and collect double digit hits in BOTH WWBA events with a combined six jacks over the two tournaments. It was a summer that combined performance and winning on the biggest stages for Romero. It’s a quiet left-handed swing that packs a punch. He would reap the benefits of his performances, earning a commitment to LSU and jumping to the #74 prospect in...
Tournaments | Story | 12/15/2025

17u Tourney All-American Team

Vincent Cervino
Article Image
There’s a lot of talent throughout this 2026 class, filled with the big-name stars, to talent that spreads across the nation. It’s been a lot of fun seeing these prospects grow and develop over the years, from the days of watching some of these guys at the 13/14u days at events on the circuit, to now where they are all graduating seniors in 2026. There’s been new faces who have popped along the way over the years, even in 2026, where some players who were relatively undiscovered, have come out and made a name for themselves with a statement performance. Between the familiar and the new, there’s a lot of names on this list that are going to be quite regularly talked about on the circuit, and for good reason.  Whether it’s PG All-Americans or not, there’s a lot of names with superstar potential at the next level. We’ve got 14 PG All-Americans...
Tournaments | Story | 12/13/2025

Finest in the Field: Class of 2029

Tyler Russo
Article Image
Finest in the Field: Class of 2026 | Class of 2027 | Class of 2028 These guys might just be entering high school, but they've certainly already made a name for themselves on the national circuit, especially with their abilities on the defensive side of things.  C: Xavier Rodriguez (Logansville, GA) Rodriguez is a polished defender with real arm strength behind the dish, while showcasing the ability to impact the baseball with authority to all fields evident by thirty of his sixty-five hits going for extra-bases including seven bombs. He handles high-level pitching extremely well, commands his staff and his offensive prowess makes him a true two-way asset. 1B: Cooper Knight (Buda, TX) Knight is a smooth operator at first base with plenty of range, fluidity and agility in his footwork around the bag. Add-in a rocket for an arm, the ability to change slots and to...
Tournaments | Story | 12/12/2025

Scout Stories: Part 5

AJ Denny
Article Image
Best Game I Saw: The Dream NTL 18U vs. MBA Scout Team Murphy Jupiter always brings out the best, and we got fireworks from the jump. Turner Marshall gave The Dream an outstanding 4+ innings of work on the mound, holding a lethal MBA team at bay with Chance Dixon, Derrick Carter, and Ellis Appling providing an offensive spark out of the gate for the Georgia based boys. However, it was only a matter of time before the talent on the other side got going, as MBA erased a 3-run deficit in the 5th to take a 4-3 lead led by a Parker Loew HR. The Dream then took command again in the Top of the 6th, before MBA punched right back with a huge 5-run inning in the bottom half capped off by a clutch RBI single from Matthew Kerrigan, ending a wild sequence with tons of notable performances from two very competitive rosters. Best Tournament Performance I Saw: Surely someone has already brought this...
Loading more articles...