THE WORLD'S LARGEST AND MOST COMPREHENSIVE SCOUTING ORGANIZATION
| 2,384 MLB PLAYERS | 15,803 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
2,384 MLB PLAYERS | 15,803 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
Create Account
Sign in Create Account
Draft  | Rankings | 4/8/2005

High School vs College Draft Debate

Perfect Game Staff
Our partner Baseball America, the #1 source for minor league prospect coverage, recently released their list of organizations with the most Minor League talent. They have ranked the organizations 1 through 30. For the study below we used the top 15 ranked clubs top 10 prospects and the other 15 clubs top 2 prospects.

To subscribe to Baseball America's on line coverage go to:
http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/

The top half

1. Angels
2. Dodgers
3. Brewers
4. Twins
5. Braves
6. Rockies
7. Indians
8. A's
9. Devil Rays
10. Cubs
11. Mariners
12. White Sox
13. Diamondbacks
14. Marlins
15. Blue Jays

We thought we would take a close look at these clubs that seem to have the most talent. Where did these players come from? Because the list is part of Baseball America's "Subscriber Only" content, we have not identified the players by name. They are listed by rank within their organization, Position, where they signed out of, and what round they were selected.

We believe there are some very interesting revelations involved in this list.

For example, the number one ranked player in every organization reveals:
18 players signed out of high school
9 players signed out of a 4 year college
3 players were signed as Free Agents out of high school.

The totals based on our test study (chart below) showing total players listed...
65 signed out of high school
51 signed out of 4 year college
43 signed as Free Agents out of high school
8 signed out of Jucos.
Interesting was the fact not a single American player was listed as a Free Agent sign.

The 8th ranked Oakland A's, not surprisingly had, by far, the most 4 year college players listed among their top 10 prospects with 7, the other 3 being Free Agents. Oakland is the only club to not have a player on their top prospect list who signed out of high school.

The clubs with the most high school players in their top 10 prospects:
#5 ranked Braves with 8
#9 ranked Devil Rays with 8
#2 ranked Dodgers with 7
#3 ranked Brewers with 7.

The #1 ranked Angels had 4 high school players, 4 Free Agents, 1 Juco and 1 four year college player among their top 10 prospects.
The #2 ranked Dodgers were 7 high school, 2 Juco and 1 Free Agent.
The #3 Brewers were 7 high school players, 2 Free Agents and 1 four year college player.
The #4 Twins were 6 high school players, 3 four year college players and 1 Free Agent.
The #5 Braves were 8 high school players and 2 Free Agents.

Looking at the top 5 rated organizations the totals show:
32 - signed out of high school
10 - signed as Free Agents (all were Latin American players)
5 - signed out of a 4 year college
3 - signed out of Juco colleges

Again looking at the overall chart that includes 180 players, there's other tidbits of info.

For example of the 180 players listed, only 54 were selected in the 1st round.

Of the top 15 ranked clubs, 11 of their #1 prospects were drafted in the 1st round. Of the bottom 15 clubs, 8 of their #1 prospects were drafted in the 1st round.

Overall, 19 clubs had a first rounder as their #1 prospect, but 11 clubs did not!

33 of the total first round picks listed in this chart signed out of high school. 5 more were supplemental first round picks, for a total of 38 out of high school.

A total of 21 of the first round picks on the chart signed out of 4 year colleges. There were no supplemental 1st round picks listed from 4 year colleges.

21 of the top prospects listed were drafted in the 10th round or later. 7 of these signed out of 4 year colleges. 8 of the later picks signed out of high school. The other 6 signed out of Junior Colleges.

The vast majority of these prospects have come out of the past four drafts.
In 2004 1st round there were 13 high school players selected, 17 four year college players.
In 2003 1st round it was 12 high school players, 17 four year college players and 1 juco.
In 2002 1st round it was 16 high school players (2 went to college rather than signing), 13 four year college players and 1 juco.
In 2001 it was 12 high school players (2 went to college rather than signing), 18 four year college players.
Total for the four years, 53 high school players selected in the 1st round (4 went to college, 49 signed)
Total for the four years, 67 college players including two juco's were selected in the 1st round. (6 returned to college, 61 signed)

The general thought is that the high school player is a bigger risk than the proven college player. This chart reveals a closer look might be in order and those with the very strongest farm systems might know something.

Of the 49 total high school 1st rounders signed from the last 4 drafts, 33 appear on the top prospects list.

Of the 67 college first rounders in the past four years, only 21 appear on the top prospects list.

Over 67 % (more than 2 out of every 3) of the high school first round picks are listed among their clubs top prospects.

Only 31% (less than 1 out of every 3) of the college first round picks are listed among their clubs top prospects.

These figures don't go along with conventional wisdom. In fact, the figures show the complete opposite. Could it be true that the high school players are not only the highest reward, but also the "least" risk?

One thing to keep in mind is that several of the players drafted in the first round are already in the Big Leagues and don't appear in the prospects chart. It would take yet another study to find out just how many of those came from college or high school. Mark Prior comes to mind immediately as a guy getting to the Majors in a hurry. There are several others college players from the past 4 years who are already in the Major Leagues. Then again there are high schoolers like Jeremy Bonderman, BJ Upton, Scott Kazmir, David Wright, Carl Crawford, etc. who have made it as well.

We are not sure what this all means, but it is very interesting. One could go through the list and come up with all kinds of opinions. The results of our little study were somewhat surprising. Especially since the draft seems to be headed more and more towards the 4 year college player. Makes one wonder why, because in this small study it appears that most of the best prospects seem to be coming out of high school.

By no means are we suggesting players should sign out of high school. In fact, for most the college route is extremely beneficial. There's no right or wrong involved, it's just a chart!

Perhaps others will read the chart and see the results differently. For those that would like to get much more information we recommend you become a Baseball America on-line subscriber.
http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/

Any comments can be emailed to pgjerry@qwest.net

Top Organizations for Minor League Talent by Baseball America (Top 15 in order)
Information is subscription only so we did not use actual players names.

(Round selected in draft highlited area)

Angels (BA RANK #1)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 1B     1    
2 3B 2        
3 SS       FREE AGENT  
4 C     1 SUP    
5 1B       FREE AGENT  
6 SS     1    
7 RHP       FREE AGENT  
8 2B   10      
9 2B       FREE AGENT  
10 RHP     3    
           
 Dodgers (BA RANK #2)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 SS       FREE AGENT  
2 RHP     1    
3 RHP     6    
4 1B     1    
5 3B   39      
6 C   17      
7 LHP     1 SUP    
8 3B     1    
9 RHP     2    
10 LHP     2    
           
 Brewers (BA RANK #3)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 2B 1        
2 1B     1    
3 SS     2    
4 RHP       FREE AGENT  
5 RHP     1    
6 OF     11    
7 RHP     10    
8 OF     4    
9 2B       FREE AGENT  
10 OF     1    
           
 Twins (BA RANK #4)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 C     1    
2 OF     12    
3 RHP 2        
4 RHP     2    
5 LHP       FREE AGENT  
6 RHP     1    
7 RHP     2    
8 3B     1    
9 SS 13        
10 RHP 2        
           
 Braves (BA RANK #5)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 OF     1    
2 3B       FREE AGENT  
3 C     2    
4 RHP     4    
5 RHP     11    
6 LHP     3    
7 SS       FREE AGENT  
8 OF     1 SUP    
9 C     1 SUP    
10 RHP     3    
           
 Rockies (BA RANK #6)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 3B     1    
2 SS     1    
3 LHP 1        
4 RHP       FREE AGENT  
5 RHP       FREE AGENT  
6 3B 4        
7 OF 2        
8 OF 8        
9 2B     1    
10 SS 10        
           
 Indians (BA RANK #7)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 RHP     1    
2 1B 1        
3 OF       FREE AGENT  
4 OF       FREE AGENT  
5 LHP 1        
6 RHP       FREE AGENT  
7 RHP     10    
8 C 3        
9 RHP   25      
10 RHP     6    
           
 A's (BA RANK #8)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 RHP 1        
2 OF       FREE AGENT  
3 RHP 1        
4 1B 7        
5 RHP 1        
6 RHP       FREE AGENT  
7 OF 1        
8 SS 1        
9 C 2        
10 OF       FREE AGENT  
           
 Devil Rays (BA RANK #9)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 OF     1    
2 LHP     1    
3 OF     32    
4 RHP   10      
5 SS     2    
6 LHP     2    
7 OF     3    
8 RHP 13        
9 RHP     5    
10 1B     4    
           
 Cubs (BA RANK #10)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 1B     2    
2 OF       FREE AGENT  
3 OF     1    
4 RHP       FREE AGENT  
5 RHP     3    
6 LHP       FREE AGENT  
7 LHP 6        
8 RHP 11        
9 RHP 2        
10 OF 14        
           
 Mariners (BA RANK #11)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 RHP       FREE AGENT  
2 OF 2        
3 OF       FREE AGENT  
4 RHP     5    
5 SS     3    
6 LHP       FREE AGENT  
7 OF       FREE AGENT  
8 SS     1    
9 OF       FREE AGENT  
10 SS       FREE AGENT  
           
 White Sox (BA RANK #12)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 OF 1        
2 OF     2    
3 RHP   17      
4 3B 1        
5 RHP 8        
6 OF     16    
7 LHP     1 SUP    
8 C       FREE AGENT  
9 SS       FREE AGENT  
10 RHP     1    
           
 Diamondbacks (BA RANK #13)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 OF 1        
2 OF 1        
3 SS     1    
4 OF 2        
5 RHP       FREE AGENT  
6 C 2        
7 OF     4    
8 3B 2        
9 RHP       FREE AGENT  
10 LHP   3      
           
 Marlins (BA RANK #14)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 OF     1    
2 LHP     6    
3 RHP       FREE AGENT  
4 1B     2    
5 C 17        
6 OF 9        
7 LHP 1        
8 LHP 2        
9 SS     2    
10 RHP 3        
           
 Blue Jays (BA RANK #15)      
BA Rank POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 RHP     2    
2 SS 1        
3 C       FREE AGENT  
4 RHP       FREE AGENT  
5 LHP 1        
6 SS 1        
7 RHP     1    
8 LHP 1        
9 RHP 2        
10 LHP       FREE AGENT  
           
           
The other 15 MLB organizations listing the top two prospects
           
Pirates        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 LHP     20    
2 C     1    
           
Padres        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 2B     4    
2 OF       FREE AGENT  
           
Reds        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 RHP     1    
2 3B     9    
           
Phillies        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 1B 5        
2 RHP     1    
           
Mets        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 OF     1    
2 RHP       FREE AGENT  
           
Astros        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 2B 1        
2 RHP       FREE AGENT  
           
Nationals        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 LHP     3    
2 1B 3        
           
Giants        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 RHP     1    
2 RHP       FREE AGENT  
           
Cardinals        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 RHP 15        
2 RHP     1    
           
Yankees        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 3B     1    
2 2B       FREE AGENT  
           
Royals        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 3B     1    
2 RHP       FREE AGENT  
           
Red Sox        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  H.S. FREE AGENT  College Free Agent
1 SS       FREE AGENT  
2 OF     8    
           
Orioles        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 OF   1      
2 RHP     5    
           
Tigers        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 OF 3        
2 RHP 1        
           
Rangers        
Name POS 4 YR College JUCO High School  High School FA College FA
1 RHP 1        
2 LHP     1    
           
Totals   51 8 65 43 0

Most 4 Year College Players among Top 10 Prospects - Oakland Athletics - 7
Most High School Players among top 10 Prospects - Devil Rays - 8, Braves - 8
Give us your feedback
Draft | Rankings | 1/12/2026

Top 100 Collegiate Freshmen
Vincent Cervino
Article Image
As we creep toward opening day here in a month or so, the draft team has put together the Top 100 freshmen on campus this spring.  Three high-end arms lead the way, starting with Jack Bauer. The Mississippi State left-hander reached triple digits as a prep and is sure to make an immediate impact this spring. UCLA right-hander Angel Cervantes was selected in the 2nd round of last year’s draft but held firm on his commitment and should be an impact arm for the Bruins. Following the arms, a collection of bats rounds out the Top 10. There is loads of upside to the group with the potential and they should draw considerable playing time as freshman.  As the list gets deeper, there are plenty of players that should pop up and make significant contributions both this year and years down the line. The class has both depth and talent, making for a very intriguing group of...
Read More
College | Story | 1/23/2026

Conference Preview: American

Craig Cozart
Article Image
2026 College Preview Index | Preseason Top 25 | Preseason Collegiate All-Americans For all of Perfect Game's conference previews as part of the 2026 college baseball preview content, the 2025 records and all-conference teams are available for free. The conference top prospects and individual team breakdowns can be viewed with a subscription. 2025 Records Teams are listed in alphabetical order*  Team W L W L UBA 24 30 8 19 Charlotte 36 22 18 9 East Carolina 35 27 13 14 Florida Atlantic 37 21 15 12 Memphis 22 33 8 19 Rice 17 40 10 17 South Florida 31 25 16 11 UTSA 47 15 23 4 Tulane 33 25 13 14 Wichita State 19 35 11 16 Preseason All-Conference Team Pos. Name School Stats/Notes C Andrew Stucky UTSA .324/.514/.467 with 6 HRs, 40 RBI; durable 6-0/192 backstop with elite defensive skills and a wealth of experience, returning 1st team all-conference member 1B Cody...
Read More
College | Story | 1/22/2026

Conference Preview: Big 10

Troy Sutherland
Article Image
2026 College Preview Index | Preseason Top 25 | Preseason Collegiate All-Americans For all of Perfect Game's conference previews as part of the 2026 college baseball preview content, the 2025 records and all-conference teams are available for free. The conference top prospects and individual team breakdowns can be viewed with a subscription. 2025 Records Teams are listed in alphabetical order*  Team W L W L Illinois 30 24 14 16 Indiana 32 24 16 14 Iowa 33 22 21 9 Maryland 27 29 12 18 Michigan 33 23 16 14 Michigan State 28 27 13 17 Minnesota 24 28 10 20 Nebraska 33 29 15 15 Northwestern 25 27 13 17 Ohio State 13 37 5 25 Oregon 42 16 22 8 Penn State 33 23 15 15 Purdue 31 23 11 19 Rutgers 29 28 15 15 UCLA 48 18 22 8 USC 37 23 18 12 Washington 29 28 17 13 Preseason All-Conference Team Pos. Name School Stats/Notes C Mason Eckelman Ohio State Taken steps forward--...
Read More
General | Blog | 1/21/2026

Wolforth Throwing Mentorship: Article 61

Ron Wolforth
Article Image
Demystifying the Curveball, Pitch Counts, and Weighted Balls- Part 1 You know what I love about the holidays? Good food, time with family, and the unspoken rule that nobody brings up religion or politics at the dinner table.   Why? Because they're powder kegs. Topics that bring out deep-seated beliefs and strong emotions.  Well, I accidentally lit one of those powder kegs recently, except it wasn't at the dinner table. It was on social media.   Our team posted a short clip of me at Boot Camp making what I thought was a pretty straightforward point: simply avoiding the curveball is far from a guarantee of arm health.   I wasn't trying to be provocative. I was just stating what I believed to be obvious after 30 years of doing this work.  But boy, did a few people have problems with it.   It became one of the most discussed posts in Ranch history....
Read More
Tournaments | Story | 1/20/2026

Back-to-Back MLK East for Phillies

Hannah Jo Groves
Article Image
TBT Phillies Scout run rules for second straight MLK East Championship The 14U TBT Phillies Scout Team overtook A3 Academy Futures 14-6 in the final game to win their second straight 2026 MLK East Championship. Though the skies were blue and the sun was out in Fort Myers, Florida, the air was very chilly. The wind whipped through the palm trees as players, parents and friends piled into the 5-Plex Player Development Complex bundled up in blankets, hoodies and beanies.  The A3 Academy Futures were first up to bat - and the TBT Phillies struggled through the first frame. The first run came across on a balk; the second came soon after off a double from Gabriel Messing. “I was surprised that they scored right away off the jump,” Kingston George said, an outfielder for TBT Phillies Scout and this year’s MVP of the 14U East MLK championship. “We were kind of quiet...
Read More
College | Story | 1/21/2026

Conference Preview: Big 12

Tyler Henninger
Article Image
2026 College Preview Index | Preseason Top 25 | Preseason Collegiate All-Americans For all of Perfect Game's conference previews as part of the 2026 college baseball preview content, the 2025 records and all-conference teams are available for free. The conference top prospects and individual team breakdowns can be viewed with a subscription. 2025 Records Teams are listed in alphabetical order*  Team W L W L Arizona 44 21 18 12 Arizona State 36 24 18 12 Baylor 33 22 13 17 BYU 28 27 10 20 Cincinnati 33 26 16 14 Houston 30 25 12 17 Kansas 43 17 20 10 Kansas State 32 26 17 13 Oklahoma State 30 25 15 12 TCU 39 20 19 11 Texas Tech 20 33 13 17 UCF 29 26 9 21 Utah 21 29 8 22 West Virginia 44 16 19 9 Preseason All-Conference Team Pos. Name School Stats/Notes C Jackson Natili Cincinnati .338/9/53; well-rounded bat with bat to ball skills and strong catch and throw 1B Brady...
Read More
Tournaments | Story | 1/20/2026

A New Path to the Next Level

Jim Salisbury
Article Image
A New Path to the Next Level: Inside Perfect Game’s College Instructional Series An important new PG event will help aspiring college players grow, get noticed COLUMBUS, Ohio -- The changing environment of college baseball has led to an innovative new event at Perfect Game, one that will connect high school players looking for an opportunity at the next level with the coaches who may be able to provide one. On top of it all, there will be plenty of expert instruction along with the spirited, tournament-style competition that PG is known for. The College Instructional Series will take place at six regionalized venues starting this summer. “This event will serve an important purpose for players and coaches,” said Adam Revelette, PG’s senior director of events. “Everybody we’ve talked to is very intrigued about the platform.” The event is geared...
Read More
Tournaments | Story | 1/20/2026

MLK West Scout Notes: Days 3-4

Steve Fiorindo
Article Image
MLK West Scout Notes: Days 1-2 Markus Chandler, RHP, Westside HS Class of 2027 A little on the undersized side as a sub 6 footer, but Chandler can generate some velo and spin.  Spun 3 frames of hitless ball for Spects National with zero walks and 6 strikeouts.  Committed to Kansas State, the righty ran the fastball to 92, living 89-92 pumping the zone with 75 percent strikes.  Looked like two different breaking balls, with the SL 80/81 (spin in 2500’s) and curveball 75/76.  No hard contact, little contact at all off the righty in this dominant outing. To follow up the pitching performance, Chandler swung the bat well on Championship Monday (Trademark Pending) with 5 RBI and three hits on the day, regularly on the barrel.  Trevor Alons, RHP, Centennial HS Class of 2028 Lean framed sophomore with a quick, whippy arm.  Playing up a few classes, you might...
Read More
College | Story | 1/20/2026

Conference Preview: Oregon State

Tyler Henninger
Article Image
2026 College Preview Index | Preseason Top 25 | Preseason Collegiate All-Americans For all of Perfect Game's conference previews as part of the 2026 college baseball preview content, the 2025 records and all-conference teams are available for free. The conference top prospects and individual team breakdowns can be viewed with a subscription. 2025 Record W L T Oregon State 48 16 1 Impact Player: Easton Talt, OF Impact Pitcher: Dax Whitney, RHP Impact Freshman: Mason Pike, RHP/MIF 2026 MLB Draft Prospects 1. Ethan Kleinschmit, LHP 2. Eric Segura, RHP 3. Zach Edwards*, RHP 4. Easton Talt, OF 5. Jacob Kreig, 1B 6. Wyatt Queen, RHP 7. AJ Singer, IF 8. Eli Gries-Smith, OF 9. Noah Scott, RHP 10. Paul Vazquez*, IF 11. Nyan Hayes, OF 12. AJ Hutcheson, RHP 13. Tyler Inge*, 3B 14. Bryson Glassco, IF 15. Jacob Galloway, C 2027 MLB Draft Prospects 1. Dax Whitney, RHP 2. Adam...
Read More
Tournaments | Story | 1/18/2026

MLK West Scout Notes: Days 1-2

Steve Fiorindo
Article Image
Cole Migaki (‘29 WA) w/ one of his 5 K’s thru 2-innings. FB 84-86 coupled w/ a firm BB that has 11/5 shape sitting 77-77. Balanced operation w/ a live, loose arm. Athletic frame at 6-ft, 170 that projects #MLKWest @PG_PacificNW pic.twitter.com/iBgAoajNUM — Perfect Game Four Corners (@PG_FourCorners) January 16, 2026 Cole Migaki (2029 Vancouver, WA) Was lights out in his start on Friday at MLK West, only needing 42 pitches to get thru three-innings and did not allow a hit or run while punching out 8.  Migaki overwhelmed opposing hitters, running his fastball up to 86 and mixing in a firm breaking ball at 75-77 with 11-5 shape and depth.  The athletic 6-foot, 170-pound right-hander is the top ranked third base prospect in the state of Washington for the class of 2029, collecting a couple of hits in his five at-bats and drove in a run.  Excellent start to...
Read More
Press Release | Press Release | 1/16/2026

Perfect Game Hires Blakeley As Regional Dir.

Perfect Game Staff
Article Image
    667 Progress Way | Sanford, FL 32771 | 319-298-2923  www.perfectgame.org | facebook.com/perfectgameusa | @PerfectGameUSA      FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE    PERFECT GAME HIRES ERIC BLAKELEY AS REGIONAL DIRECTOR    Sanford, Florida (Friday, January 16, 2026) - Perfect Game, the world’s largest youth baseball and softball platform and scouting service, today announced the hiring of Eric Blakeley as a Regional Director. Blakeley brings more than two decades of experience in elite baseball and softball events, along with an accomplished background as both a collegiate and professional player.    Blakeley joins Perfect Game after building the highly respected Crossroads Baseball Series, where for more than 20 years he developed and operated baseball...
Read More
Loading more articles...
About Perfect Game :: Contact us :: Terms of Use :: Privacy Policy :: Testimonials :: Job Opportunities
Copyright 1994-2026 by Perfect Game. All rights reserved. No portion of this information may be reprinted or reproduced without the written consent of Perfect Game.