THE WORLD'S LARGEST AND MOST COMPREHENSIVE SCOUTING ORGANIZATION
| 2,493 MLB PLAYERS | 15,806 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
2,493 MLB PLAYERS | 15,806 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
General  | Top Ten | 10/9/2008

Playoffs Are A Crapshoot

With the Chicago Cubs and Los Angeles Angels, the teams with the best regular-season records in their respective leagues, making hasty exits this year from post-season play by going a combined 1-6 in the National and American League Division Series, and the Boston Red Sox positioned to win their third World Series in five years as a wild-card entry, it has become apparent that playoff baseball in the wild-card era has become a crapshoot.

No longer is the World Series winner necessarily the game’s best team or rightful champion.

Not when a wild-card team has won the World Series four times, one less than a team that posted the best record in its league has. Not when nine wild-card teams have reached the World Series, one less than a team with the best record in its league has. Not when the teams that have posted the 10 best records in the wild-card era, as the accompanying chart shows, have won just a single World Series (the 1998 New York Yankees).

Since the three-division, wild-card format was introduced in 1994 and that year’s World Series was promptly cancelled, the teams with the best records in their respective leagues have gone 144-112 (.562) in post-season play. By contrast, wild-card teams have gone a collective 129-117 (.524). That’s not a profound difference, especially when wild-card teams have never had home-field advantage in any series.

National League wild-card teams (69-64) have even done better in the post-season through the years than the teams with the best record (63-60), highlighted, of course, by the improbable World Series success enjoyed in 1997 and 2003 by the Florida Marlins—a team that has never finished in first place, yet has two World Series trophies.

Throughout much of its rich history, baseball has resisted allowing anything but first-place teams from participating in post-season play as it sought to preserve the sanctity and integrity of a 154-game or 162-game regular season.

It didn’t want to go the direction of the NHL or NBA, which historically have opened the door to the post-season to more than half the teams in their leagues—even some very undeserving sub-.500 teams. As a result, it’s not uncommon in those leagues that the recognized champion is, rightly or wrongly, not the same team that had the best regular-season record. Even the 64-team NCAA basketball tournament, for all the excitement it generates, rarely crowns a truly deserving champion. The more games in a single-elimination format, the greater chance for an upset.

In baseball, pretty much until 1995 when the number of playoff teams was doubled, the team that won the World Series deserved to win or was at least a worthy champion, based on their regular-season performance.

There’s little question that the wild-card concept and expanded playoffs have been wildly popular as the game has enjoyed unparalleled popularity over the last 15 years, but it’s apparent that the more teams that are involved in post-season and the more the standards are lowered to include more teams, the less likely it is that a rightful champion will emerge.

How else do you explain a wild-card team winning the World Series three years in a row from 2002 to 2004, or a wild-card team advancing to the World Series in each of the last six years—with the Red Sox primed to make it seven in a row? How else do you explain the St. Louis Cardinals winning the 2006 World Series, despite an anemic 83-78 regular season record?

The Chicago Cubs, on the 100th anniversary of their last World Series victory, deserved a better fate than having a 97-win season go up in smoke in a playoff system that does little, if anything, to reward regular-season success—particularly in a best-of-5 division series. Ten times in the wild-card era has the team with best record in its league been knocked out in the Division Series. By contrast, wild-card teams have gone an unfathomable 16-12 in first-round series.

If anything, the Division Series should be expanded to a best-of-7 affair on the rationale that the better, more deserving team will generally win over the long haul. But consideration should also be given to awarding a first-round bye to the team in each league with the best record, or to giving teams with the best records a decided home-field advantage—like five, or maybe even six home games, in a best-of-7 series.

It also wouldn’t hurt to have post-season play become more representative of the daily grind of the regular season, where the incessant number of off days that are created to pacify TV networks are eliminated. It would force teams to use the same fourth and fifth starters that got them to the post-season in the first place.

Until such changes are incorporated—if they are ever incorporated—we can expect to see the same random champions that we’ve become accustomed to seeing. The attached list honors the teams with the 10 best regular-season records in the wild-card era (1994-2008), and includes their regular-season record, their post-season record (an aggregate 48-45) and their post-season fate:
Rank Team Year Season Record *W-L Post-Season Fate
1. Seattle Mariners 2001 116-46 (.716) 4-6 Lost to Yankees in ALCS
2. New York Yankees 1998 114-48 (.704) 11-2 Won World Series
3. Cleveland Indians 1995 100-44 (.694) 9-6 Lost to Braves in World Series
4. Atlanta Braves 1998 106-56 (.654) 5-4 Lost to Padres in NLCS
5. St. Louis Cardinals 2004 105-57 (.648) 7-8 Lost to Red Sox in World Series
6. New York Yankees 2002 103-58 (.640) 1-3 Lost to Angels in ALDS
7. Atlanta Braves 1999 103-59 (.636) 7-7 Lost to Yankees in World Series
  Oakland Athletics 2002 103-59 (.636) 1-3 Lost to Red Sox in ALDS
9. Atlanta Braves 2002 101-59 (.631) 2-3 Lost to Cubs in ALDS
10. Houston Astros 1998 102-60 (.630) 1-3 Lost to Padres in NLDS
*Post-Season Record

General | Blog | 6/16/2026

Wolforth Throwing Mentorship: Article 66

Ron Wolforth
Article Image
  The Number That Just Killed MLB Expansion: 1,217   USA Today's Bob Nightengale dropped a bomb shell recently that the baseball world is still digesting. Major League Baseball wants to expand to 32 teams. Team executives are quietly opposing it and the reason has nothing to do with cities or money.   They cannot find enough healthy pitchers.   Between 2020 and 2024, professional baseball performed 1,026 Tommy John surgeries at the minor-league level alone. Another 191 at the Major League level. More than twelve hundred elbow reconstructions in five years on the best young pitchers in the world.   That is not bad luck. That is a system reporting a verdict on itself.   For fifteen years, the youth-baseball industry has chased one number: velocity significantly more than projectability and arm care.    Recruiters scout by it.    Social...
Tournaments | Story | 7/6/2026

16u WWBA Rolls Into Marietta

Will Dembo
Article Image
More than 300 of the nation’s top 16u teams will meet in East Cobb, Georgia this week as the 16u WWBA Championship gets underway. Over 50 ranked teams from across the country will compete for one of the most prestigious titles in travel baseball, drawing scouts and fans from all over. Pool play will commence on Monday, July 6th with the championship game set for July 13th at the storied East Cobb Baseball Complex. Canes National 16u will hold honors of being the top ranked team entering the event as they have earned a No. 2 national ranking following a dominant 17-2-1 start to their season. The highly touted program is home to many of the top ranked prospects from the 2028 class including talented two-way athlete, Grant Arnold (No. 12 overall) who lives in the 90’s from the mound as well as middle infielder, Bryan Mesa (No. 14 overall) who will draw lots of attention this...
College | Story | 7/6/2026

USA Collegiate National Team: Stars

Craig Cozart
Article Image
Quick Hits  Each year at the end of June and beginning of July, top collegiate baseball talent from around the nation arrives in Cary, NC at the USA Baseball National Training Complex.  Typically, the rosters are filled with top underclass, non-draft-eligible talent but this year, we will see a sprinkling of upper-classmen as the coaches evaluate just under 60 players to get to their final 28 roster spots.  For a total of two weeks, the Stars Squad and the Stripes Squad will compete against outside competition in North Carolina as well as Virginia before finishing their slate with 5-games against each other at the NTC Complex.  Once the final roster has been announced the team will depart for Taiwan to compete in the 2026 World Baseball Championships, July 11-15.    CNT Stars Position Players  Anthony Pack Jr.  FR / OF / University of Texas ...
Draft | Mock Draft | 7/6/2026

MLB Mock Draft: 4.0

Tyler Henninger
Article Image
MLB Draft: Top 500 Update Pick Team Name Pos. School 1 Chicago White Sox Roch Cholowsky SS UCLA 2 Tampa Bay Rays Grady Emerson SS Fort Worth Christian 3 Minnesota Twins Vahn Lackey C Georgia Tech 4 San Francisco Giants Jacob Lombard SS Gulliver Schools 5 Pittsburgh Pirates Jackson Flora RHP UC Santa Barbara 6 Kansas City Royals Drew Burress OF Georgia Tech 7 Baltimore Orioles Eric Booth Jr. OF Oak Grove 8 Athletics Chris Hacopian SS Texas A&M 9 Atlanta Braves Ryder Helfrick C Arkansas 10 Colorado Rockies Tyler Bell* SS Kentucky 11 Washington Nationals Jared Grindlinger LHP/OF Huntington Beach 12 Los Angeles Angels Cameron Flukey RHP Coastal Carolina 13 St. Louis Cardinals AJ Gracia OF Virginia 14 Miami Marlins Derek Curiel OF LSU 15 Arizona Diamondbacks Gio Rojas LHP Marjory Stoneman Douglas 16 Texas Rangers Liam Peterson RHP Florida 17 Houston Astros Justin Lebron SS Alabama 18...
Tournaments | Story | 7/5/2026

13u World Series Notes: Days 1-2

Perfect Game Staff
Article Image
Michael Wedgeworth (2030, Flomaton, AL) had put the two way ability on full display so far this week, dominating from both sides. On the mound Wedgeworth ran the fastball up to 84 (81-83) with ease to the delivery. Broke off a couple nasty curveballs that induced swing and miss, as well as freezing hitters for punch outs. Collected six in his four inning complete game. He also would not be denied at the plate going 3-5 in the first two days with two doubles. Very intriguing young player as the body continues to grow.  Tyler Bellush (2031, Summerville, SC) is a sure handed shortstop for the Canes Nation squad. Swings it from the left side of the plate and the barrel accuracy has really stuck out thus far. 3-4 through the first couple days with a double and two triples, Bellush has also walked twice and collected 3 RBI along the way. Yesterday against USA Prime with the bases loaded,...
Tournaments | Story | 7/4/2026

16u WWBA North Scout Notes

Perfect Game Staff
Article Image
Oliver Lindstrom (2028, Green Bay, WI) created some of the loudest offensive moments of the weekend while producing across the board, finishing with six hits, eight RBI, and a home run. The right-handed hitter showed the ability to stay through the baseball and drive it with authority. Creates quality leverage through the lower half while arriving in strong hitting positions early, allowing the barrel to work with intent through the zone. The blend of power, athleticism, and all-fields impact stood out throughout the event.  Dominic Haigh (2028, South Bend, IN) was one of the most productive hitters at the event, collecting 10 hits while consistently creating pressure on opposing defenses. Made life difficult on pitchers with a relentless approach, routinely extending at-bats and forcing them to work deep into counts. The operation remains simple and efficient, featuring an early...
Tournaments | Story | 7/4/2026

West Region Rankings Risers: Class of 2028

Joey Cohen
Article Image
After a heavy stretch of early summer looks, our scouting staff felt confident rolling out an updated ‘28 national ranking a couple weeks ago. The evaluation window was packed whether it was with our Memorial Day and Summer Kickoff tournaments, UBC action, Sunshine Showcases, and of course the Junior National Showcase which all provided a deep and diverse look at the class against strong competition. Between fresh game evaluations and updated showcase data, we were able to get a clearer picture of where players stand and more importantly how they’ve progressed. Improvements in strength, athleticism, and overall skill were evident across the board giving our staff real conviction when it came time to shuffle the board. With that in mind, I wanted to highlight a handful of west region prospects who made a strong impression on me this summer and earned a well-deserved jump in...
All American Game | Story | 7/3/2026

Initial 2026 All Star Game Roster Reveal

Article Image
We are excited to announce the first selections for the 2026 PG All Star Game from both the Perfect Game Junior and Sophomore National Showcases. The PG All Star Game will be held on Friday, August 14th at Citizens Bank Ballpark, the home of the Philadelphia Phillies, and will feature roughly 40 of the top players, predominately from the 2028 class with a few of the very best 2029s also selected. A watchlist has been created from the Junior National Showcase and another group of players will be selected from that showcase towards the end of July as we continue to evaluate players at the major Perfect Game tournaments this summer. The final wave of selections we be made at the PG Underclass All American Games August 5-7 at the UCSD in San Diego, CA. PG Underclass All American Games   Junior National Selections Dexter McCleon Jr. OF Suwanee, GA USA Prime Cullen Scott RHP/3B Melissa,...
Tournaments | Story | 7/3/2026

13u WWBA Scout Note Recap

Jheremy Brown
Article Image
Walter Izquierdo Jr. (2031, Miami, Fla.) showed off the upside on the mound for Beast Baseball 13u. The right-handed pitcher went four innings and collected three strikeouts while spreading two hits and two walks for one run. The fastball topped out at 80 and was consistently in the upper- 70s. Showed feel for a curveball with 12-6 shape and some looser vertical depth that was able to get weak contact. Competes in the zone well and showed some feel to work on the arm-side half of the plate. Intriguing upside on the young arm.   Brett Hamlin (2031, Jupiter, Fla.) showed off the barrel feel for FTB American 13u. The left-handed hitter collected nine hits, including two doubles and a triple, to drive in seven RBI. Strong hands and flips the hips well to create good bat speed. Simple operation that gets on time consistently and impacts the ball well. Worked the pull-side well and...
Tournaments | Story | 7/2/2026

Freedom Classic Opens Holiday Weekend

Alyssa Golden
Article Image
More than 30 teams from the 14U-18U age divisions will head to Fort Myers, Florida this Fourth of July weekend for the seventh annual Perfect Game Freedom Classic. The tournament, running July 3-6, features several nationally ranked prospects from across the country as teams look to compete for a championship. Headlining the field are twin brothers Derek and Ryan Yormark of Merrick, New York. Right-handed pitcher Derek Yormack is the No. 51-ranked player in the class of 2027, the No. 1 player in New York and the No. 5-ranked right-handed pitcher in the country. First baseman Ryan Yormark comes in just behind his twin brother as the No. 3 overall player in New York, the No. 5 first baseman in the nation and the No. 90-ranked player nationally. Both brothers are committed to Vanderbilt. Derek Yormark has established himself as one of the top two-way prospects in the 2027 class. He has run...
Tournaments | Story | 7/2/2026

14u West World Series Scout Notes

Quinton Hall
Article Image
Asher Contreras (2030 | Las Vegas, NV) The 5-foot-10, 170-pound right-handed hitter and outfielder was one of the most dangerous hitters in the tournament for Wow Factor Nv 2030, stuffing the stat sheet while displaying an impressive combination of power and speed. He finished the weekend with 9 hits, including two doubles and a home run, while driving in seven runs and scoring five more. He also swiped three bases and worked three walks, consistently putting pressure on opposing defenses while showing feel for the zone with just one strikeout all weekend. His ability to hit for extra bases while also creating offense on the bases made him one of the most impactful offensive performers at the event.    Braylen Silva (‘30 | NV) RBI 2B for GBG Vegas 14u Red. Direct path, quick trigger, & barrel feel. Solid 2-hole stick creating offense all day #14UWestWS...
Loading more articles...