The San
Francisco Giants didn’t need to win the World Series for other teams to be
envious of their starting pitching. They have entered the past two years as
legitimate playoff contenders because of that staff, despite having a lineup
full of question marks and well-traveled veterans.
So while most
sports are considered copycat leagues, this win isn’t going to cause teams to
suddenly realize they have to improve their own efforts to procure a high level
of pitching talent. They already knew
that.
It starts
with the Giants’ ace and the two-time reigning NL Cy Young Award winner, Tim
Lincecum. He led the league in strikeouts for the third consecutive season, even
if his overall numbers across the board appeared to be a little less dominant
than the previous two. In the postseason he went 4-1 and 2-0 in the World
Series, winning both the first and the last games of the Series.
Fire-balling
Matt Cain didn’t allow a single run in three postseason starts and was
particularly dominant against the Phillies and Rangers. He went 2-0, allowing
only six hits in 14.2 innings during his National League Championship Series
and World Series appearances.
Lefty
Jonathan Sanchez didn’t fare quite as well in the postseason, going 0-2
(someone had to lose games for the Giants), but he didn’t receive a decision in
a masterful effort over the Braves in the National League Division Series. He
also posted the best ERA in the regular season for the Giants at 3.07.
Madison Bumgarner, just 21 years old,
represented the fourth member of the Giants’ postseason starting rotation.
After a brief stint with the team late last year, he returned to AAA Fresno for
a 14- game tuneup before resuming his big league career. That happened in late
June, and 18 starts later he enjoyed a 2-0 postseason of his own, including
eight shutout innings against the Rangers in game four of the World Series.
San Francisco
accomplished its victory without its big free-agent acquisition from the
2006-07 offseason, Barry Zito, who was left off of the playoff roster. Manager
Bruce Bochy knew his starting staff would go only four deep in the playoffs and decided not to carry the veteran lefty in
his bullpen.
(That move
alone was somewhat of a microcosm of how this team was managed and played. No one seemed to be stuck in any one role –
Aubrey Huff, the team’s best hitter, bunted with runners on first and second in
the final game of the series – and the lineup never looked the same from one
day to the next.)
Not only was
this group of pitchers collectively good, but they also stayed healthy.
Lincecum, Cain, Sanchez and Zito all started 33 games. Bumgarner started 18 in
a row since his callup, replacing Todd Wellemeyer, who made 11 starts for the
Giants. Only one other pitcher made a start for the Giants all year long. Joe
Martinez (who was traded at the deadline along with John Bowker for Javier
Lopez of the Pirates) made one start in mid-June.
That means only
seven pitchers made starts for the Giants this year.
Lincecum and
Cain easily surpassed 200 innings pitched, while Zito and Sanchez just missed
(199 and 193, respectively).
Even more
astonishing is that Lincecum, Cain, Sanchez and Bumgarner (all right, Martinez
as well) were all drafted and developed entirely from within.
Lincecum
(2006), Cain (2002) and Bumgarner (2007) were all first-round picks, while
Sanchez went in the 27th round in 2004.
Joining
Sanchez as a late-round success story from the Giants’ drafting and player
development success is closer Brian Wilson, who led all of baseball in saves
this past year with 48 and continued his dominance into the postseason. In 10 postseason games, he recorded six saves
and allowed only five hits, striking out 16 batters in 11.2 innings.
Bullpen mate
Sergio Romo was also drafted by the Giants (28th round in 2005) and was a big
part of their success.
However, the
starters were so good, it didn’t even seem as though the Giants needed much of
a bullpen. After the first game of the World Series, in which six relievers
were used by San Francisco to get through the final 4.1 innings, the bullpen
was used for only 6.1 more innings across the four final games. Wilson tossed
two of those frames, recording saves in games four and five.
It should be
noted that almost all of the teams pitched well this postseason. The Yankees
and Twins were the only teams to post a staff ERA over 3.80, with four teams
below the 3.00 mark, and one (Atlanta Braves, 1.95) below 2.00.
There is more
internal help on the way for San Francisco.
Hard throwing
left-handed reliever Dan Runzler was eased into big-league life this year,
making 41 appearances but tossing only 32.2 innings. Waldis Joaquin, another
hard-throwing reliever, has also spent some time in the big-league bullpen with
the Giants each of the last two years, but inconsistent control has limited
those stints. Henry Sosa is another live-armed righty that is on the cusp of
contributing to the big-league ‘pen, and Jason Stoffel could be fast-tracked
for a similar role.
They are a little
thin in true starters in the upper levels, not that they need them. The organization’s best prospect and the
sixth overall pick from the 2009 draft, Zack Wheeler, made his professional
debut this past season and fared quite well for the Augusta Greenjackets at the
low-A level. Lefty Clayton Tanner, coming off of a solid season at the AA
level, should be prepared to help out next season should the team need a
starter from within.
You won’t
find too much rhyme or reason to what kind of pitchers the Giants draft. They
seem to prefer bigger guys with equally big arms, but that didn’t stop them
from taking Lincecum, and they certainly don’t shy away from high school arms.
Quite simply, they are the best at what they do best.
Good enough
Don’t expect
the Giants’ starting lineup to be copied by any team in the near future.
Watching and listening to most of the games throughout the playoffs, I often
heard the usual cliches about how this was the Giants’ year, and how they were
destined to win it all. Looking at some of the names in their lineup, this is
the one year I actually buy into those cliches.
Huff had a
fine year, batting .290/.385/.506 while leading the team with 26 home runs and
86 RBIs. He also led his club in runs scored with 100, seemingly low totals for
a team leader in those categories.
Rookie Buster
Posey led the team in batting with a .305 average, the only Giants hitter to
hit above the .300 mark.
Andres Torres
led the club in doubles and was the only player on his team to have more than seven
stolen bases with 26.
Joining Posey
and Huff as regulars in the everyday lineup were Pablo Sandoval (who didn’t
play nearly as much during the postseason) and Juan Uribe. Torres, Edgar
Renteria, Cody Ross, Pat Burrell, Aaron Roward, Travis Ishikawa and Freddy
Sanchez were all juggled in and out of the lineup to receive regular, if not
consistent, playing time for the other four spots in the lineup.
You don’t
have to crunch the numbers too far to recognize this truly was a team effort,
but don’t slap the small-ball label on this team, either. Collectively they
only stole 55 bases (second to last in the NL) and were caught another 32
times, a far less than desirable 63 percent success rate.
They were
also fairly good at hitting the ball over the fence, finishing sixth in the
league in both home runs and slugging, seventh in batting and ninth in runs
scored.
The three
previous World Series winners finished first, second and third in their leagues
in runs scored and boasted names such as Alex Rodriguez, Mark Teixeira, Derek
Jeter, Ryan Howard, Chase Utley, Jimmy Rollins, Kevin Youkilis, Manny Ramirez
and David Ortiz.
I’m not
saying the Giants are an anomaly, as the team achieved success quite similar to
how the White Sox did so in 2005. The Sox also finished ninth in the league in
runs scored with a relative group of no-namers in their starting lineup, while
also boasting the American League’s best pitching staff.
Outside of
Posey, the Giants haven’t fared quite as well developing their own impact hitters
from within. Sandoval enjoyed a huge season in 2009, but dropped back
significantly this past year with serious questions about his body and
conditioning. First-round picks Nick Noonan and Conor Gillaspie haven’t hit as
well as expected, although both spent the year at the AA level. While the team has increased and improved its
presence in Latin America, the $2.1 million they gave Angel Villalona at this
point in time seems to be a giant mistake.
They have
seemed to recognize the need for more bats in their system, using five of their
top six picks from the last two years on hitters. In addition, first baseman
Brandon Belt enjoyed a breakout year, spending time at three levels this past season,
and he is now knocking at the door to the big leagues and may be considered a
replacement for Huff, a free agent.
Outfielder Thomas Neal continued to progress with another strong season
at the AA level. Another outfielder, Francisco Peguero, is another example of
the Giants’ increased spending in Latin America, as he too enjoyed a big year
one step below Neal.
Regardless of
how they are built, their strengths and their weaknesses, it will be difficult
for the Giants to repeat for the simple fact that in the last 10 years – after the
Yankees’ dominance in the late 1990s – only one team (Boston Red Sox) has won
more than one World Series.
The
thoughts and opinions listed here do not necessarily reflect those of Perfect
Game USA. Patrick Ebert is affiliated with both Perfect Game USA and 5
Tool Talk, and can be contacted via email at pebert@5tooltalk.com.