THE WORLD'S LARGEST AND MOST COMPREHENSIVE SCOUTING ORGANIZATION
| 2,384 MLB PLAYERS | 15,801 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
2,384 MLB PLAYERS | 15,801 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
Create Account
Sign in Create Account
Draft  | Story | 10/5/2010

Pirates sit atop 2011 draft order

Efforts have been made in Pittsburgh to build for the future, trading away some of their pricer commodities for prospects and spending more aggressively in the draft.  So with the focus on the future, it’s not too big of a surprise that things got worse for the Pirates this season, finishing with the worst record in all of baseball while securing the first overall pick in next year’s draft.
 
The Pirates haven’t had a winning season since 1992.  Their average draft position from 1994 to last year was 7.5.  In the last 10 years (2001-2010) their average draft position was 4.7.  2011 will mark the third time the Pirates have owned the first overall pick during that span, taking Kris Benson and Bryan Bullington with the first pick in 1996 and 2002 respectively.
 
Speaking of those two players, Benson had a respectable career, but after showing flashes of brilliance early, he for the most part fizzled away.  Bullington, along with several other top pitching prospects selected with first-round picks (John VanBenschoten, Sean Burnett, Bobby Bradley and Clint Johnson), had their aspiring careers derailed by injury.
 
Brad Lincoln, the fourth overall pick from 2005, has also seen his career path slowed due to injury.  The eighth overall pick in the 2003 draft, Paul Maholm, has stayed healthy, but only has one full season under his belt with an ERA under 4.44.  Daniel Moskos, the fourth overall pick from 2007, has returned to his more comfortable role coming out of the bullpen in the minor leagues.
 
The Pirates have had a little more luck with positional prospects.  Pedro Alvarez, the second overall pick from 2008, had a nice debut this past season for the Pirates, and has plenty of room for improvement.  Neil Walker, the team’s first-round pick from 2004, finally made a mark at the big-league level, settling in at second base.  Their 2005 first-round pick, Andrew McCutchen, continued to play well and is one of the more exciting young players in the league.
 
After they were heavily criticized for passing on superior talents such as Matt Wieters with the fourth overall pick in 2007 for financial reasons, the Pirates loosened the purse strings in 2008 when it took six million dollars to lock up Alvarez.  They spent $8.7 million on their top 13 picks in 2009 and another $8.75 million on their top two picks from last year’s draft, Jameson Taillon and Stetson Allie.
 
So money shouldn’t play too big of a factor in their decision next June, and after finishing last in the National League in both ERA and runs scored, they shouldn’t get too cute trying to decide between a positional prospect or a pitcher.  The four players currently discussed as the likely candidates for that pick include right-handed pitcher Gerrit Cole of UCLA, lefty Matt Purke of TCU, third baseman Anthony Rendon of Rice, and outfielder George Springer of UConn.
 
If you’re a Pirates’ fan wondering if the Buccos may be the next big sleeper team to make a dramatic turnaround, consider that worst to first scenarios, or at least close to them, have happened twice in the last decade.
 
The Minnesota Twins, who owned the first overall pick in 2001 (the year they took Joe Mauer), finished 85-77, a 16-game improvement from the year before.  Starting the following year in 2002, the Twins have made the postseason six times in nine seasons.
 
The Rays made it to the World Series as part of the 2008 season, the same year they owned the first overall pick (the second year in a row that they did so).  While the Rays’ 31 games improvement from 2007 to 2008 was a huge surprise, they had a lot more talent in place than what the Pirates currently do.
 
In other words, you would have to hope a lot of things go right next year to pick the Pirates as a sleeper.  Slowly but surely the Pirates are accumulating impact talent, but it’s going to take some more time and patience for the pieces to come together.  The number one overall pick in next year’s draft will help bridge that gap.
 
A few other notes about the draft order:
 
•  The Pirates aren’t the only team that can’t seem to get out of the cellar.  The Orioles and Royals assumed their usual spots among the top five overall picks at fourth and fifth respectively. 
 
•  What appeared to be a breakout season a year ago, the Seattle Mariners dropped back down to earth, securing the second overall pick for next year’s draft as they did in 2009.  The 16 pick drop was the largest of any team from the 2010 to 2011 raw draft order.
 
•  The San Diego Padres had the largest jump in the draft order, going from ninth to 25th.  After not signing the ninth overall pick this past year (Karsten Whitson), the Padres have a pair of first-rounders in the raw draft order.
 
•  Both the Diamondbacks (third and seventh) and Brewers (12th and 15th) also have a pair of first-round picks since they didn’t sign their 2010 first-round picks (Barret Loux and Dylan Covey respectively).
 
•  The Mariners will receive a supplemental third-round selection for not signing third-rounder Ryne Stanek, the only other player in the top three rounds that did not sign by the August 16 deadline.
 
This is how the raw draft order in the first round stacks up with the end of the regular season (winning percentage in parenthesis -- tie-breakers are awarded to the team that finished with the worse record the previous year):
 
1.  Pirates (.352)
2.  Mariners (.377)
3. Diamondbacks (.401)
4.  Orioles (.407)
5.  Royals (.414)
6.  Nationals (.426)
7.  Diamondbacks (unsigned ’10 first-rounder Barret Loux)
8.  Indians (.426)
9.  Cubs (.463)
10.  Padres (unsigned ’10 first-rounder Karsten Whitson)
11.  Astros (.469)
12.  Brewers (.475)
13.  Mets (.488)
14.  Marlins (.494)
15.  Brewers (unsigned ’10 first-rounder Dylan Covey)
16.  Dodgers (.494)
17.  Angels (.494)
18.  Athletics (.500)
19.  Tigers (.500)
20.  Rockies (.512)
21.  Blue Jays (.525)
22.  Cardinals (.531)
23.  White Sox (.543)
24.  Red Sox (.549)
25.  Padres (.556)
26.  Rangers (.556)
27.  Reds (.562)
28.  Braves (.562)
29.  Giants (.568)
30.  Twins (.580)
31.  Yankees (.586)
32.  Rays (.593)
33.  Phillies (.599)
 
Be sure to stayed tuned to Perfect Game in the coming days for Allan Simpson’s top 300 prospects for the 2011 draft and top 200 list for 2012.
 

The thoughts and opinions listed here do not necessarily reflect those of Perfect Game USA.  Patrick Ebert is affiliated with both Perfect Game USA and 5 Tool Talk, and can be contacted via email at pebert@5tooltalk.com.


Draft | Rankings | 12/24/2025

Top 2027 Collegiate Draft Prospects

Isaiah Burrows
Article Image
With the 2025 cycle officially behind us and the calendar nearly flipping over to 2026, it is time to start looking ahead to the future. More importantly, start looking ahead to the next season of college baseball and what that may mean for draft-eligible players with big dreams of continuing their journey. While the 2026 MLB Draft is now on the horizon, we are looking ahead to the future even further – to see which players have already made impacts upon their arrival to college campuses. We have already dropped our 2028 Top 75 collegiate prospects board, but this one is our Top 100 college prospects who will be eligible for the 2027 class. These are the Top 100 players in our eyes for this group, and many of them have already shown up on campus and been impactful in many ways. Whether its our top-ranked player in Oregon State’s Dax Whitney or ninth-ranked William Schmidt...
High School | General | 12/24/2025

2025 Year In Review: High School

Cam McElwaney
Article Image
IMG Academy Takes Home the National Title Every year IMG Academy comes into the spring with top-to-bottom one of the top rosters in the country and every year have the expectation of winning the national championship. Well in 2025 they did just that after finishing the spring 24-1, winning the High School Showdown, and winning 15 straight games to end their season. Their high end offensive ability was on full display throughout the year and they will once again be one of the most talented teams in the country in ’26 as they look to go back-to-back. Two Top-10 Picks in the MLB Draft Headline National Players of the Year It was another loaded crop that took home the National Players of the Year as both Ethan Holliday, the National Player of the Year, and Seth Hernandez, National Pitcher of the Year, heard their names called within the first-10 picks in the MLB Draft. Another first...
Draft | Rankings | 12/23/2025

Top 2028 Collegiate Draft Prospects

Vincent Cervino
Article Image
The college players in the 2028 draft class have yet to step on campus, but they're positioned to make an immediate impact. Several high end talents either turned down significant money last year or honored strong college commitments, resulting in their arrival on campus this fall. The class is currently led by a trio of high-upside arms in Jack Bauer, Angel Cervantes, and Cameron Appenzeller. They are followed by a deep group of bats that rounds out a strong, high end Top-10. Rk. Name Level Pos. B-T School Hometown State 1 Jack Bauer C LHP L-L Mississippi State Frankfort IL 2 Angel Cervantes C RHP R-R UCLA Lynwood CA 3 Cameron Appenzeller C LHP L-L Tennessee Springfield IL 4 Brayden Jaksa C C R-R Oregon Fremont  CA 5 JD Stein C SS R-R Wake Forest Carmel IN 6 Mason Ligenza C OF L-L Pittsburgh Brockton PA 7 Ty Peeples C OF L-R Georgia Lavonia GA 8 Lucas Franco C SS L-R TCU Katy TX 9...
Juco | Story | 12/23/2025

2025 Year in Review: JUCO

Blaine Peterson
Article Image
Looking Back at the 2025 Top 10  Matt Barr (‘25 Niagara, ‘26 Minnesota Twins) Bursting onto the scene last winter, footage of an indoor bullpen rocketed Barr onto the radar of many. Explosive fastball reaches near triple digits with incredible spin numbers across the secondaries. Huge numbers at Niagara earned him the title of the first Juco player drafted in 2025. JC Vanek (‘25 Chipola, ‘26 Kansas City Royals) Just a professional hitter. Vanek for two years at Chipola was an impossible out. While there are questions if the power will ever reach what it takes to play first base at the big league level, the bat and quality defensive skillset at first base may carry. Donovan Becerra (‘25 New Mexico, ‘26 Texas Tech) One of the more high octane arms anywhere in the country last year. Can reach back for upper 90’s and has shown serious swing and...
Draft | Story | 12/22/2025

2025 Year in Review: Draft

Isaiah Burrows
Article Image
2025 Year in Review: Draft We’ve reached the end of the 2025 calendar year, and while we’ve already jumped in on the 2026 cycle with some of the fall events and post-draft content we’ve had here at Perfect Game, there’s still one more piece on the docket, and that’s the 2025 Year-In-Review piece here from the PG Draft staff.  The 2025 MLB Draft took place in July, when many highly talented players heard their names called and continued their journey through the game to the next level. There’s already been some of those names making noise in the minors and guys who are moving up prospect lists and becoming names to know for MLB fans digging deep into the future of their organizations. While we are going to “close the book” on 2025 with this article, these players still have many years ahead of them, and many blank pages to continue...
College | Recruiting | 12/22/2025

Recruiting Notebook: December 22

Jheremy Brown
Article Image
Lucien Saint Cyr, INF, Class of 2026 Commitment: Bucknell Saint Cyr announced his pledge to Bucknell, giving the Bison an interesting blend of present tools and projection. Saint Cyr stands 6-foot-1 and offers room to fill in his medium frame, profiling in the middle infield defensively. The New York product starts wide at the base in the right-handed box, keeping his hands high behind the ear. He works into a subtle outward step load, firing through a compact barrel that showcases bat speed and gap-to-gap impact. For head coach Scott Heather and Bucknell, they land a high-quality Northeast infielder in the ’26 cycle, adding to a class that takes the quality over quantity approach. Patrick Diaz ('26, NY) 102 EV off the bat. Impact to the pull side. #PGNational @PGMidAtlantic @PG_Uncommitted pic.twitter.com/NN0L3FRdO9 — PG Showcases (@PGShowcases) July 9, 2025 Patrick Diaz,...
High School | General | 12/19/2025

Huntington Beach HS World Series Recap

Steve Fiorindo
Article Image
MVPitcher: Duncan McLeod The uncommitted junior toed the slab in three of the four games for Team Mick, tossing 3 2/3 innings.  Zero walks, zero hits and 6 punchouts for the lefty who was used both as a starter in the series clinching game 4 and he closed out game 3 on Friday in quick fashion.  McLeod was very efficient as well, needing just 42 pitches over all his outings.  In the game 4 start, over two innings he punched out 3, with one strikeout with all of his offerings.  The mid 80’s fastball regularly played up, set up with efficient use of the secondaries, with the breaking ball 73/74 and fading change-up 72-74.   Owen Bone (2026) at it again... Solo shot in the 5th to tie things up. Back to back days with a home run for Bone. #PGHS pic.twitter.com/2JC9qETI5h — Perfect Game California (@California_PG) December 13, 2025 MV Hitter: ...
Tournaments | Story | 12/19/2025

13u Tourney All-American Team

Jheremy Brown
Article Image
What a year it was in 2025 on the national landscape at the 13u level as Perfect Game continues to expand its reach around the country, providing an even bigger schedule of events coast-to-coast which has allowed players all over show out and gain their deserved recognition. Whether in Texas for the Houston 1000 or the 13u WWBA in West Palm Beach, we saw huge, eye opening performances from the players placed below, knowing that we could EASILY build a third team and likely a fourth without much effort.  As we do every year with this exercise, it's worth pointing out the trickiness of this age group and putting the teams together with the 13u group. While the players are all members of the Class of 2030, some are younger for the grade, which allowed them to play at the 12u level where's it's a smaller field, shorter mound distance and different bats, so we'll separate them out and...
Tournaments | Story | 12/18/2025

14u Tourney All-American Team

Tyler Russo
Article Image
Player of the Year: Asher Williams It was an incredible year for Williams that was rewarded with a trip to the 14U Select Fest, before some more impressive play in the fall. He came to the plate almost 250 times in PG tournaments throughout 2025 and reached base in well over half of them, hitting to a .500 AVG while slugging a 14U circuit best 12 bombs and driving in 113 runs. The numbers on the surface are ridiculous, but when you look at the high-level events he put them up in, it makes it even more impressive. Pitcher of the Year: Tristan Blalock Blalock earns this honor after a dominant 2025 where he struck out 85 batters in just 48.2 innings of work with a minuscule 1.58 ERA. This included several strong performances at many national level tournaments and showcases where he was able to bully some of the best hitters in the country. It’s hard not to fall in love with...
Draft | Story | 12/18/2025

PG Draft: Gut Feel Guys

Tyler Henninger
Article Image
While we are nearing the turn of the calendar to the 2026 year, that means we are just inching closer to the beginning of the season for many high school players and college baseball is on the horizon. We are prepping for a reshuffle of the 2026 MLB Draft Board as well here amongst the PG Draft staff. But before we get to that, we sat down and have each picked a couple of players who are in the mix to get selected in a couple of different buckets.  We have prospects who could go into the Top 30 picks or so, prospects who could be selected in the Top 5 rounds, and prospects who could go inside of the Top 10 rounds. With the draft quite far down the road and a lot of re-shuffling to be done as these players play themselves into certain spots on the draft board, our scouts picked some players who fit into these “buckets” who are gut-feel guys. These are the guys that our PG...
Loading more articles...