THE WORLD'S LARGEST AND MOST COMPREHENSIVE SCOUTING ORGANIZATION
| 2,631 MLB PLAYERS | 16,402 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
2,631 MLB PLAYERS | 16,402 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
Draft  | Mock Draft | 5/11/2016

2016 MLB Mock Draft Version 1

Photo: Tim Casey




2016 Perfect Game MLB Draft Preview Index | 2016 MLB Draft Order

Trivia Quiz: Name the top 5 leaders in WAR among first overall picks since the draft was instituted in 1965 (answer below). 

2016 will again be a year without an obvious No. 1 pick, something that has arguably become an annual circumstance since Stephen Strasburg, Bryce Harper and Gerrit Cole were picked first overall all in 2009, 2010 and 2011, respectively. That leaves the Phillies with a pool of perhaps four to five players to realistically choose from, plus a potentially huge chip to play, the $9,015,000 draft slot value that comes with it.

If the Phillies use their cards intelligently, they will play those players off against one another looking to save as much money as possible to use in later rounds. If they are successful, as the Astros were in 2012 with Carlos Correa (but somehow inexplicably didn't do the next two years), they could have upwards of $6 million left to spend over the rest of their draft class and still get the player they want.

A quick list of five potential players the Phillies could easily consider might look like this: High school pitchers Jason Groome and Riley Pint, high school outfielder Blake Rutherford, Louisville outfielder Corey Ray and Florida lefthander A.J. Puk.

A long-time industry aversion to high school pitchers at the top of the draft is in play here and talk in the scouting community is that the Phillies are inclined to follow that historical trend. The two outfielders are outstanding prospects and should become above average big leaguers but lack the wow tool factor of a Justin Upton or a Josh Hamilton as a No. 1 overall pick. Historically it is fairly rare for outfielders to be picked first overall, having happened only six times since 1984.

The first installment (of three) of the Perfect Game mock draft, as it has been in past years, is a collaborative effort between the draft team of David Rawnsley, Jheremy Brown, Brian Sakowski, Andrew Krause, Patrick Ebert and 2080 Baseball's Nick Faleris. The picks (the top 41 selections, through the Competitive Balance Lottery Round A) were evenly distributed between the six participants. Since the draft is still almost a month away, these picks are not meant to be an accurate prediction of which players will be taken at which slots, but rather an exercise pairing the top picks with the individual team's recent draft history and overall preferences, as well as the thoughts of our individual draft experts.

Trivia Answer (WAR as of opening day, 2016): Alex Rodriguez (1993) 118.5; Chipper Jones (1990) 85.0; Ken Griffey Jr. (1987) 83.6; Joe Mauer (2001) 48.8; Adrian Gonzalez (2000) 42.4. Bryce Harper (21.0) and David Price (28.8) should join the Top 5 within a few years.


Follow us on Twitter:

@DavidRawnsleyPG | @JBrownPG | @akrausePG
@PGPatrickEbert | @ B_Sakowski_PG | @NickJFaleris




1. Philadelphia Phillies | A.J. Puk, LHP, Florida
Despite some early season struggles, which have not been uncharacteristic for the Iowa native, Puk has been showing No. 1 starter stuff more and more often as the season progresses. He's the best choice right now for the Phillies, who are well into a rapid rebuilding of their system and will benefit from Puk's age and experience, if not high ceiling. (DR)


2. Cincinnati Reds | Corey Ray, OF, Louisville
Ray provides a dynamic combination of tools, including an ability to hit for average and power, plus speed and solid arm strength. The Chicago area prep product is lauded for his work ethic and makeup, each of which are evident in the development of his game over the past 30 months and his physical transformation from a lean and projectable teen to a 21-year old that looks like he leg presses dump trucks in his spare time. (NF)


3. Atlanta Braves | Jason Groome, LHP, Barnegat HS (N.J.)
The Braves would be ecstatic to get Groome here as he’s a 6-foot-6, easy-armed lefthander who regularly works in the mid-90s with the fastball, his curveball is a potential plus pitch and the changeup is coming along very well. Oh, and he’s young for the grade, and the overall command and repeatability of his delivery also rank among the best in the class. Simply put there isn’t much Groome can’t do. (JB)


4. Colorado Rockies | Riley Pint, RHP, St. Thomas Aquinas HS (Kan.)
Pint may have the highest upside of any player in this draft, and his impressive arsenal has him in the running to become the first high school righthanded pitcher ever selected No. 1 overall. He's taken a big jump forward this winter/spring, consistently sitting in the upper-90s and touching triple digits with his heater and flashing plus or better with both his changeup and power curveball. (AK)


5. Milwaukee Brewers | Delvin Perez, SS, International Baseball Academy (P.R.)
While coming dangerously close to pulling the trigger on Kyle Lewis here, the Brewers decide to go with the tantalizing tools and impact upside of Delvin Perez, the (very) young Puerto Rican. Perez won't turn 18 until well after draft day, and flashes the potential for five average or better tools while being arguably the best infield glove in the draft in addition to potentially having big-time impact with the bat.  (BS)

This is PG 'DiamondKast' Level content.
You must be either an DiamondKast, Crosschecker Rankings & Scouting Reports, or Scout subscriber to read the rest.

Sign in Subscribe Now

Draft | Prospect Scouting Reports | 10/15/2026

Beyond the Board: C/UTL Gavin Kelly

Tyler Henninger
Article Image
Beyond the Board: SS Dylan Seward As the 2027 draft cycle moves through the fall and into the offseason, we kick off a new series called Beyond The Board. With each installment, we will provide an in-depth scouting report for some of the top players in the class, breaking down their tools, strengths, question marks, and overall projection. This week we are diving in West Virginia’s Gavin Kelly. The Mountaineer backstop posted a .382/.477/.725 slash line with 19 home runs, 44 extra-base hits, and helped lead WVU to Omaha in ‘26. Let’s dive in.  Player: Gavin Kelly  Position: C/UTL B/T: R/R Height: 6-foot-0 Weight: 175-pounds School: West Virginia Hometown: Pittsburgh, Pen. Physical Description: 6-0/175. Lean, athletic build. Sneaky strength throughout. Frame has room to fill out and get stronger.    Slo-mo look at the HR by Gavin Kelly (@WVUBaseball)....
Tournaments | Story | 10/24/2026

SBA Takes 14u Title Behind Offense

Jheremy Brown
Article Image
To say there were standouts all over the field for the 14u WWBA World Championship would be an understatement as the matchup of Team Elite 14u Scout and SBA Bolts National 14u saw two of the more loaded rosters going head-to-head with a title on the line. And after weather threw a giant wrench into pool play, both Sunday and Monday were nothing but sunshine and high intensity baseball leading into the final game of the event.  While the game ultimately ended via run rule after five in favor of SBA upon a 9 run inning, it was a tight contest up until that point with Team Elite carrying a 3-2 lead thru four innings.  Team Elite drew first blood as a Ross Logan walk quickly turned into the first run of the game following a well struck single by Cooper Ooten into left field who eventually came around to score following a double steal, scoring before the third out of the inning was...
Softball | Softball Tournament | 10/22/2026

PG Softball Chesterfield Fall Showcase High School Division

Erica Beach
Article Image
PG Softball Chesterfield Fall Showcase HS Division Oct 17-18, 2026 Chesterfield First Community Athletic Complex CHESTERFIELD, MO — It was a perfect weekend for softball, with 16 teams converging on the Chesterfield First Community Athletic Complex to compete in the High School Division. Teams from Illinois, Minnesota, and Iowa were there to battle it out, and there was only one undefeated team in the tournament: the Southeast Iowa All-Stars 16U Gold Flowerbach, who went a stellar 5-0 on the weekend. We were treated to some stellar performances all weekend and below we highlight some of the standout athletes who caught our eyes.  Lucy Turner (2027, Marion, IA) of the Cedar Rapids Reds was a truly dynamic two-way player this past weekend. Offensively, she batted .444 with 5 RBIs and an impressive 6 stolen bases, which led the tournament. She also scored 6 runs for her team and...
Tournaments | Championship | 10/22/2026

Wildcatters Reign Supreme at 13u WWBA

Jheremy Brown
Article Image
After both the Best of the West and the Beast of the East wrapped up, a big conglomerate of high end talent and stacked teams descended upon West Palm for both the 13u and the 14u WWBA World Championships. While the weather threw a wrench into the plans early on and some adjustment was needed to ensure the event moved forward, it was nothing but sunshine and competitive baseball throughout Sunday and into the early morning Monday.  Kicking off with the 13u WWBA World Championship, the first thing to point out is the fact this was a wood bat tournament played on 60-90 fields and while the combo was a first for most, you wouldn't know it with their level of play throughout the weekend. In an unsurprising twist and a continuation of their 12u dominance, the 13u championship saw the #2 seeded Goldin Prospects lock horns with the top seeded Houston Wildcatters, aka the champion of the...
Tournaments | Story | 10/22/2026

17u Coastal Fall Invitational

Perfect Game Staff
Article Image
Dalton Fisher (2028, China Grove, NC) stands at 6-foot-2, 180 pounds, with a lean, projectable frame and room to add strength as he develops. Bats and throws right-handed and plays the outfield. Shows a good approach at the plate with quick hands, solid bat speed, and the ability to drive the ball to all fields. Fisher went 2-for-3 with 1 RBI, putting together a great day at the plate. Bradley Edwards (2028, Summerville,SC) Stands at 6-feet-5 225 strong build and the potential to generate considerable power. Bats and throws right handed is a right handed pitcher. Shows good arm strength and the ability to attack hitters while generating swings and misses. Demonstrates a competitive approach on the mound with the ability to challenge hitters in the zone. Recorded 4.2 innings pitched with 10 strikeouts, a 56% strike rate, and a fastball that topped out at 85 mph. Jackson Pierce (2028,...
Softball | Softball Tournament | 10/21/2026

PG Softball Chesterfield Fall Showcase 14U Division

Erica Beach
Article Image
2026 PG softball Chesterfield fall showcase 14U Division October 17th to 18th Chesterfield First Community Athletic Complex CHESTERFIELD, MO — It was a highly competitive weekend of softball as six teams battled it out on the field. In the end, the Midland Magic Wooster finished with a flawless 5-0 record, showcasing a dominant tournament performance by allowing only three runs while exploding for 65 runs of their own. Below we highlight some of the weekend’s shining stars. \ Abigail Doolittle (2030 - Edwardsville, Illinois) of Top Gun 2030-IL established herself as one of the tournament's most formidable hitters over five games, posting an astounding .727 batting average. Showcasing elite power and versatility, she racked up three singles, two doubles, two triples, and a home run. Doolittle drove in four runs, scored four times, drew a walk, and added a stolen base....
Tournaments | Story | 10/21/2026

Windy City Finale Scout Notes

Perfect Game Staff
Article Image
‘27 RHP Jaxson Weiss (IL) pitched well in his 5 innings and put up some eye popping strikeout numbers. He punched out 10 and allowed only 2ER. FB T86 early and flashed a BB 72-75. #WCFinale https://t.co/M8GtCUgxyS — Perfect Game Illinois (@PG_Illinois) October 17, 2026 Jaxson Weiss (2027, New Lennox, Ill.) a right-handed pitcher put up big strikeout numbers in his start on Saturday. He worked five innings while punching out ten opposing hitters. The fastball topped out at 86 mph and sat in the 82-85 mph range most of the game. His breaking ball was his primary off-speed, living 72-75 mph. Weiss keeps his body under control throughout his delivery, helping him with his good command on the mound. He uses his lower half well with a nice leg drive and gets his hips through, guiding his backside. He pitched with confidence and stayed ahead of hitters most of the game. Hayden...
Tournaments | Story | 10/19/2026

PG Draft: Jupiter Draft Movers

Tyler Henninger
Article Image
The WWBA World Championship remains one of the premier events on the draft calendar as all 30 major league organizations descend on Jupiter to evaluate some of the top talent in amateur baseball. The event serves as a pivotal checkpoint in the scouting process, giving established prospects an opportunity to further elevate their stock while lesser-known names have a chance to put themselves on the radar of various organizations. This year was no exception, as several players made strong impressions and positioned themselves for increased attention heading into the spring. With that being said, let’s dive into a few draft risers and sleepers who stood out in Jupiter. Calum Andersen (‘27,CAN) had his A stuff working today running the FB to 96 mph with a devastating horizontal SL at 85 mph that can break bats. Mixed in a late breaking 12/6 curveball at 78 mph that induces weak...
Tournaments | Story | 10/20/2026

Jupiter Recap: Stars Being Stars

Vincent Cervino
Article Image
WWBA World Championship Notes: Day 1 | Day 2 | Day 3 | Day 4 PG Draft: Jupiter Draft Movers With the 2026 WWBA World Championship in the rearview mirror, we're going to begin our breakdowns of 4 different subcategories, beginning today with the Stars Being Stars category. Most of the players below are household names or were teetering on the edge of such recognition, using Jupiter as their launching pad. From Perfect Game All-Americans to some serious helium names for the MLB Draft, the PG crew breaks them all down below.  ‘27 Samir Mohammed (FL) racked up 11 Ks thru 5 IP on 75% strikes. FB lived 98-99, T100 w/ tons of ASR & life thru the zone. Hit 99 mph 10+ times incl his final pitch of the outing. Had his sharp vert CB on a string & faded the CHG effectively vs LHHs (clip). #LSU commit. @PG_Draft #WWBAWorlds @Florida_PG — Perfect Game Scout (@PG_Scouting)...
Tournaments | Story | 10/21/2026

Jupiter Recap: Uncommitted...For Now

Kyler Peterson
Article Image
WWBA World Championship Notes: Day 1 | Day 2 | Day 3 | Day 4 PG Draft: Jupiter Draft Movers | Jupiter: Stars Being Stars Gets your reads in now because by the time you reach the end, some of the talent in this article might be giving their commitments to a college somewhere across the country. Every player below did something that caught out scout's eye and should certainly be on the radar for college coaches, if they aren't already.  Braxton Sykes (2028, Brunswick, Ga.) tossed a total of six innings down in Jupiter, collecting six strikeouts while failing to allow either a hit or earned run during his tenure on the mound. The 6-foot-2 right-hander showcased an impressive three-pitch mix with excellent feel to locate in every part of the strike zone. His fastball lived in the mid- to upper-80s mph range with more velocity to project for as Sykes continues to add strength and...
Tournaments | Story | 10/23/2026

Jupiter Recap: The Next Wave

Kyler Peterson
Article Image
WWBA World Championship Notes: Day 1 | Day 2 | Day 3 | Day 4 PG Draft: Jupiter Draft Movers | Jupiter: Stars Being Stars | Jupiter: Uncommitted...For Now | Jupiter: Breakout Prospects You don't have to look too hard into the future to see what the prep game has in store as the players below are already showing tools beyond their years. With a slew of 2028 and 2029 grads more than holding their own in Jupiter, the scene for the upcoming summer has already had some groundwork laid out for what should be an exciting couple of years to come.  ‘28 Alan Zimmerman (FL) racked up 5 Ks w/ just 1 H allowed thru 3 shutout frames. Lived 89-90 T91 w/ lots of life thru the zone & some ASR. Dropped in a 12/6 breaker for Ks (clip). Projectable 6’3” mold. #Uncommitted @PG_Uncommitted #WWBAWorlds @Florida_PG https://t.co/KTDFpGK49y — Perfect Game Scout...
Loading more articles...