| Team | # | Last | First | Grad | Pos | Other Pos | City | State | High School |
| Gold | 19 |
Boling
|
Brandon
| 2009 | RHP | OF | Lexington | KY | Bryan Station |
| Gold | 8 |
Brindle
|
Eric
| 2009 | MIF | 3B, OF | Pickerington | OH | Pickering North |
| Steel | 8 |
Brown-Lewis
|
Tyler
| 2010 | SS | OF, RHP | Shaker Heights | OH | Shaker Heights |
| Gold | 23 |
Gomez
|
Niko
| 2009 | C | 1B | Chicago | IL | St. Ignatius College Prep |
| Crimson | 9 |
Hohl
|
Brandon
| 2009 | MIF | 3B, OF | Mokena | IL | Lincoln Way East |
| Gold | 6 |
Kammer
|
Jeff
| 2010 | C | OF | Wildwood | MO | Lafayette |
| Gold | 5 |
Kraus
|
Jared
| 2009 | IF | OF, RHP | Cedar Rapids | IA | Xavier |
| Orange | 6 |
Marinier
|
Scott
| 2009 | RHP | | Orland Park | IL | St. Rita |
| Gold | 10 |
Mottashed
|
Luke
| 2009 | C | MIF | Cary | IL | Cary-Grove |
| Orange | 4 |
Murphy
|
Andrew
| 2009 | C | | Green Bay | WI | Bay Port |
| Orange | 23 |
Naumann
|
Jake
| 2009 | RHP | | Naperville | IL | Naperville North |
| Orange | 7 |
Payton
|
Mark
| 2010 | OF | 1B, LHP | Orland Park | IL | St. Rita |
| Steel | 18 |
Schuch
|
Bob
| 2009 | OF | | Evergreen Park | IL | Brother Rice |
| Steel | 3 |
Seacrist
|
Chuck
| 2011 | RHP | 1B, 3B | Painesville | OH | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin |
| Crimson | 21 |
Stirling
|
Mike
| 2009 | RHP | 3B | Thornton | IL | Mt.Carmel |
| Crimson | 3 |
Suarez
|
David
| 2010 | RHP | 3B | Peru | IL | LaSalle-Peru |
| Steel | 9 |
Trecaso
|
Samuel
| 2009 | 3B | RHP, SS | Cuyahoga Falls | OH | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary |
