| GS Surge Team Akadema Prospects | 12 | Jacob Acevedo | 2019 | Memorial | West New York | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Frazier Sox | 40 | Khaniel Alba | 2019 | Middletown South (Middletown, NJ) | Middletown | NJ | USA | OF |
| Northern Valley Coyotes | 17 | Armando Alvarez | 2019 | Don Bosco Prep | River Vale | NJ | USA | 1B |
| Oil City Bandits | 9 | Anthony Ambrosino | 2018 | Archbishop Molloy | Howard Beach | NY | USA | 1B |
| Oil City Bandits | 31 | Louis Annunziata | 2019 | The Churchill School And Center | Queens | NY | USA | C |
| Northern Valley Coyotes | 5 | Joseph Argenziano | 2019 | Northern Valley Regional | Closter | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Wladyka Baseball | 22 | Nicholas Argenziano | 2019 | Northern Valley Regional | Closter | NJ | USA | 3B |
| North Jersey Bandits | 1 | Wildert Arias | 2018 | Passaic Co Tech | Paterson | NJ | USA | RHP |
| North Shore Vikings | 7 | Marc Aufiero | 2019 | North Shore Senior (Glen Head, NY) | Glen Head | NY | USA | RHP |
| Wladyka Baseball | 1 | Dave Backo | 2019 | Wallington Jr Sr | Wallington | NJ | USA | 2B |
| Stars and Strikes | 25 | Michael Bafunno | 2019 | Crestwood | Wapwallopen | PA | USA | OF |
| New Jersey Rangers | | Michael Baginski | 2020 | Millville | Millville | NJ | USA | 3B |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 17 | Caleb Bailey | 2020 | Old Mill | Severn | MD | USA | OF |
| Gallagher Team Mizuno | 13 | Ryan Bearse | 2019 | Howell | Howell | NJ | USA | RHP |
| All Pro Stars 2019 | | Brennan Beatrice | 2019 | Bellport Senior | Brookhaven | NY | USA | 2B |
| Long Island Tigers 2019 | 9 | Stephen Benson | 2019 | Massapequa | Massapequa | NY | USA | 3B |
| Jersey Wolfpack | 7 | Dan Berckman | 2020 | Cherry Hill West | Cherry Hill | NJ | USA | SS |
| Oil City Bandits | 1 | Chris Betancourt | 2018 | | Oceanside | NY | USA | 3B |
| Team SSK Crush | 52 | Robert Beyer | 2019 | Fordham Preparatory | Bedford | NY | USA | 1B |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 54 | Vincent Bianchi | 2019 | Red Bank Catholic | Middletown | NJ | USA | SS |
| Complete Performance Baseball Academy | 29 | Sean Bielitz | 2019 | St. Mary's | Clifton | NJ | USA | LHP |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 3 | Dhane Blair | 2020 | St. Mary's | Cheltenham | MD | USA | OF |
| Team Citius Elite | 18 | Zachary Blumberg | 2019 | Baruch College Campus | New York | NY | USA | RHP |
| LIB Expos National | 42 | Alex Boburka | 2019 | Summit (Summit, NJ) | Summit | NJ | USA | RHP |
| HV Bulldogs | 10 | Quentin Bowman | 2020 | Roy C Ketcham Senior | Wappingers Falls | NY | USA | C |
| Team Citius Elite | 20 | Connor Bradshaw | 2020 | Trinity-Pawling | New Rochelle | NY | USA | OF |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 11 | McCormick Buchner | 2020 | St. Mary's | Annapolis | MD | USA | LHP |
| North Shore Vikings | 23 | Mike Capobianco | 2018 | Glen Cove (Glen Cove, NY) | Glen Cove | NY | USA | RHP |
| Oil City Bandits | 30 | Daniel Cardito | 2019 | Kellenberg Memorial | Malverne | NY | USA | OF |
| All Pro Stars 2019 | | Vance Carlo | 2019 | William Floyd | Mastic Beach | NY | USA | 2B |
| New Jersey Rangers | | Justin Cassella | 2020 | Seton Hall Preparatory | Bernardsville | NJ | USA | SS |
| Long Island Outlaws | 15 | Joseph Chirico | 2018 | Commack (Commack, NY) | Smithtown | NY | USA | OF |
| LIB Expos National | 11 | Nick Chraca | 2019 | Parsippany Hills | Morris Plains | NJ | USA | OF |
| New Jersey Nationals | 42 | Quincy Clark | 2019 | Seton Hall Preparatory | West Orange | NJ | USA | RHP |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 7 | Tommy Criscuolo | 2019 | | Staten Island | NY | USA | 3B |
| Northern Valley Coyotes | 3 | Matt D'Amato | 2019 | Bergen Catholic | Midland Park | NJ | USA | OF |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 2 | Sam Daniels | 2020 | St. Mary's | Millersville | MD | USA | RHP |
| Long Island Outlaws | 21 | Nicholas Decicco | 2018 | Commack (Commack, NY) | Commack | NY | USA | SS |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 17 | Thomas Denlinger | 2019 | Montgomery | Skillman | NJ | USA | SS |
| Elite Baseball Training | 7 | Randy Diaz | 2017 | | Bronx | NY | USA | SS |
| Jersey Wolfpack | 0 | Elijah Dickerson | 2019 | Rancocas Valley | Mount Holly | NJ | USA | OF |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 50 | TJ DiGiacomo | 2019 | | Staten Island | NY | USA | OF |
| Team SSK Crush | 15 | Stephen Donato | 2019 | Westlake (Thornwood, NY) | Thornwood | NY | USA | RHP |
| Frazier Sox | 33 | Dan Donnelly | 2019 | | Hazlet | NJ | USA | 3B |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 28 | AJ Donofrio | 2019 | Gill St Bernard's | Far Hills | NJ | USA | C |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 15 | Dylan Donohue | 2019 | Union Catholic | Union | NJ | USA | 3B |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 3 | Gregory Dorfman | 2019 | Midwood | Brooklyn | NY | USA | RHP |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 3 | George Eberle | 2019 | Voorhees | Califon | NJ | USA | 3B |
| All Pro Stars 2019 | | Matt Encizo | 2019 | Longwood | Ridge | NY | USA | SS |
| Elite Baseball Training | 42 | Conrad Fallon | 2019 | IMG Academy | New York | NY | USA | RHP |
| Frazier Sox | 27 | Connor Fern | 2019 | Jackson Memorial | Jackson | NJ | USA | LHP |
| PS2 Academy Crusaders | 4 | Julius Ferreira | 2019 | Manchester Reg H (Haledon, NJ) | Prospect Park | NJ | USA | OF |
| Team Citius Elite | 23 | Daniel Fichtl | 2019 | Bronx High School Of Science | New York | NY | USA | 2B |
| Jersey Wolfpack | 6 | Evan Francisco | 2020 | Moorestown (Moorestown, NJ) | Moorestown | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Jersey Wolfpack | 18 | Dom Frigiola | 2020 | Shawnee | Medford | NJ | USA | 3B |
| Sachem Warriors | 23 | Anthony Gambino | 2020 | Eastport-South Manor (Manorville, NY) | Manorville | NY | USA | C |
| All Pro Stars 2019 | | Danny Gargano | 2019 | Longwood | Middle Island | NY | USA | RHP |
| PS2 Academy Crusaders | 44 | Cole Gentile | 2019 | Mahwah (Mahwah, NJ) | Mahwah | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Jersey Seminoles | 6 | Michael Ghiorsi | 2019 | Ramsey | Ramsey | NJ | USA | RHP |
| LIB Expos National | 7 | Michael Giammarino | 2019 | Gill St Bernard's | Basking Ridge | NJ | USA | LHP |
| Long Island Outlaws | 7 | Joseph Giglio | 2018 | Sachem East (Farmingville, NY) | Holtsville | NY | USA | RHP |
| YSL BlueDevils | 26 | Geudy Gil | 2018 | Bushwick Leaders Hs For Academic Excellence | Brooklyn | NY | USA | RHP |
| PS2 Academy Crusaders | 9 | Alessandro Gioino | 2020 | Wayne Hills (Wayne, NJ) | Wayne | NJ | USA | RHP |
| YSL BlueDevils | 14 | Clarence Givhans | 2018 | Abraham Lincoln | Brooklyn | NY | USA | LHP |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 9 | Christian Gonzalez | 2019 | Tottenville | Staten Island | NY | USA | SS |
| North Jersey Bandits | 6 | Jesus Gonzalez | 2019 | Paterson Catholic High Schl | Paterson | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Team SSK Crush | 1 | Jackson Goodman | 2019 | Fordham Preparatory | Eastchester | NY | USA | RHP |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 8 | Hunter Griebel | 2020 | Kent Island | Stevensville | MD | USA | RHP |
| LIB Expos National | 14 | Matt Hallberg | 2019 | Morristown | Morristown | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Long Island Marlins | 34 | Bryan Hanlon | 2018 | Manhasset Secondary | Manhasset | NY | USA | OF |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 27 | Cole Hansen | 2021 | Montgomery | Skillman | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Jersey Seminoles | 11 | Nick Harper | 2019 | Don Bosco Prep | Westwood | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Gallagher Team Mizuno | 37 | Jerry Hewitt | 2019 | Rancocas Valley | Lumberton | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Langan Baseball | 9 | Daniel Hirujo | 2019 | Matawan Regional High School | Aberdeen | NJ | USA | 1B |
| New Jersey Rangers | | Braedin Hunt | 2020 | Christian Brothers Academy | Old Bridge | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Long Island Marlins | 27 | Conor Jacoby | 2018 | New Hyde Park Memorial (New Hyde Park, NY) | New Hyde Park | NY | USA | LHP |
| Frazier Sox | 21 | Connor Keenan | 2019 | Jackson Liberty | Jackson | NJ | USA | OF |
| Jersey Seminoles | 25 | Jonathan Kim | 2019 | Tappan Zee | Sparkill | NY | USA | RHP |
| Stars and Strikes | 98 | Ian Kishbaugh | 2019 | Berwick Area (Berwick, PA) | Berwick | PA | USA | 3B |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 5 | Garrett Koch | 2019 | Warren Hills Reg | Asbury | NJ | USA | OF |
| HV Bulldogs | 18 | Rj Kruse | 2019 | Delaware Valley | Milford | PA | USA | 1B |
| Langan Baseball | 16 | Michael Kuver | 2019 | Manalapan | Manalapan | NJ | USA | OF |
| LIB Expos National | 19 | Drake Lam | 2019 | West Morris Mendham | Mendham | NJ | USA | 2B |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 52 | Ben Levine | 2019 | Manalapan | Manalapan | NJ | USA | LHP |
| North Shore Vikings | 12 | Danny Livoti | 2019 | North Shore Senior (Glen Head, NY) | Glen Head | NY | USA | RHP |
| All Pro Stars 2019 | | Nicholas Lomonaco | 2019 | William Floyd | Shirley | NY | USA | OF |
| Stars and Strikes | 99 | Evan Long | 2019 | Bloomsburg Area (Bloomsburg, PA) | Bloomsburg | PA | USA | RHP |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 19 | Ben Looper | 2019 | Oakland Mills | Columbia | MD | USA | 1B |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 6 | Ryan Looper | 2019 | Oakland Mills | Columbia | MD | USA | RHP |
| Langan Baseball | 24 | Nick Loschiavo | 2019 | Monroe Twp | Monroe Twp | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Midville Dodgers 2019's | 49 | Eric Luebcke | 2019 | Monsignor McClancy Memorial | East Elmhurst | NY | USA | RHP |
| Sachem Warriors | 25 | John Madigan | 2019 | Sachem East (Farmingville, NY) | Holbrook | NY | USA | RHP |
| NJ Yankees | 33 | Anthony Marchetto | 2019 | Saddle Brook | Saddle Brook | NJ | USA | SS |
| YSL BlueDevils | 15 | Eslinyer Marinez | 2018 | John Bowne (Flushing, NY) | Corona | NY | USA | 3B |
| Long Island Tigers 2019 | 99 | Kelvin Marte | 2020 | Twin Tiers Baptist | Middletown | NY | USA | LHP |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 33 | Brandon Martinez | 2019 | Tottenville | Staten Island | NY | USA | OF |
| Long Island Marlins | 8 | James May | 2018 | Kellenberg Memorial (Uniondale, NY) | New Hyde Park | NY | USA | 3B |
| Stars and Strikes | 97 | Mark McCracken | 2019 | Berwick Area (Berwick, PA) | Wapwallopen | PA | USA | RHP |
| All Pro Stars 2019 | | Josh McGee | 2019 | Connetquot | Ronkonkoma | NY | USA | C |
| Jersey Seminoles | 41 | Andrew Meisener | 2019 | Oratory Prep | Berkeley Heights | NJ | USA | 1B |
| Elite Baseball Training | 24 | Bryant Melo | 2018 | Monroe Academy For Visual Arts & Design | Bronx | NY | USA | OF |
| New Jersey Rangers | | Andrew Menichelli | 2020 | Northern Burlington | Jacobstown | NJ | USA | OF |
| Langan Baseball | 12 | Vincent Mentesana | 2019 | Christian Brothers Academy | Manalapan | NJ | USA | LHP |
| All Pro Stars 2019 | | Peter Montana | 2019 | Connetquot | Ronkonkoma | NY | USA | RHP |
| Jersey Wolfpack | 14 | Rj Moten | 2020 | Delran | Delran | NJ | USA | OF |
| New Jersey Nationals | 31 | Brian Mueller | 2019 | Seton Hall Preparatory | Bedminster | NJ | USA | 1B |
| New Jersey Rangers | | Ian Muni | 2020 | West Windsor-Plainsboro South | Princeton Junction | NJ | USA | LHP |
| Long Island Marlins | 42 | Michael Munoz | 2019 | New Hyde Park Memorial (New Hyde Park, NY) | New Hyde Park | NY | USA | RHP |
| Complete Performance Baseball Academy | 32 | Kevin Nelson | 2019 | Pequannock Twp | Pompton Plains | NJ | USA | RHP |
| HV Bulldogs | 21 | Brandon Ortiz | 2020 | Warwick Valley | Warwick | NY | USA | SS |
| North Jersey Bandits | 16 | Ismael Ortiz | 2018 | John F Kennedy | Paterson | NJ | USA | C |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 29 | Hunter Parish | 2019 | Old Mill | Glen Burnie | MD | USA | C |
| Gallagher Team Mizuno | 10 | Joseph Pence | 2020 | Bishop Eustace Prep | Mount Laurel | NJ | USA | OF |
| Midville Dodgers 2019's | 25 | Nicholas Perez | 2020 | St. Francis Prep (Queens, NY) | Bayside | NY | USA | RHP |
| Wladyka Baseball | 13 | Wesley Pierorazio | 2019 | Northern Valley Regional | Norwood | NJ | USA | OF |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 77 | Matthew Pleszewicz | 2019 | Moore Catholic | Staten Island | NY | USA | 3B |
| North Jersey Bandits | 4 | Anderson Polanco | 2019 | Eastside | Paterson | NJ | USA | 3B |
| Team Citius Elite | 29 | Christopher Polgano | 2019 | St. Raymond HS For Boys | Bronx | NY | USA | 3B |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 10 | Michael Ragona | 2020 | Moore Catholic | Staten Island | NY | USA | OF |
| Gallagher Team Mizuno | 24 | Jason Ramirez | 2020 | Princeton | Princeton | NJ | USA | RHP |
| NJ Yankees | 4 | Mike Ramundo | 2019 | De Paul Catholic | Lincoln Park | NJ | USA | SS |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 44 | Trent Rathell | 2020 | | Pasadena | MD | USA | 2B |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 22 | Joseph Reitano | 2019 | Xaverian | Staten Island | NY | USA | 2B |
| YSL BlueDevils | 17 | Luis Reyes | 2018 | Puerto Rico | Bronx | NY | USA | C |
| Gallagher Team Mizuno | 24 | Michael Reyes | 2019 | South Brunswick | Monmouth Junction | NJ | USA | LHP |
| PS2 Academy Crusaders | 32 | Justin Roa | 2019 | Emerson | Emerson | NJ | USA | C |
| Stars and Strikes | 1 | Alex Robenolt | 2018 | Danville Area | Danville | PA | USA | OF |
| North Jersey Bandits | 43 | Jeffrey Rodriguez | 2020 | International | Paterson | NJ | USA | 2B |
| YSL BlueDevils | 20 | Jose Rodriguez | 2018 | Christ The King Regional (Middle Village, NY) | Brooklyn | NY | USA | LHP |
| Wladyka Baseball | 20 | Mike Rodriguez | 2019 | Pascack Hills | Montvale | NJ | USA | RHP |
| YSL BlueDevils | 21 | Ricardo Romero | 2018 | William Cullen Bryant | Queens | NY | USA | 1B |
| YSL BlueDevils | 7 | Tommy Rondon | 2019 | John Bowne | Elmhurst | NY | USA | OF |
| Rawlings Prospects A's MD | 24 | Michael Rosen | 2019 | Mount Saint Joseph | Ellicott City | MD | USA | 1B |
| Team Citius Elite | 21 | Alex Santos | 2020 | Mount St Michael Academy | Bronx | NY | USA | RHP |
| Complete Performance Baseball Academy | 42 | Trevor Santos | 2020 | Nutley | Nutley | NJ | USA | OF |
| Northern Valley Coyotes | 34 | Daniel Scacchetti | 2020 | Pascack Valley | River Vale | NJ | USA | OF |
| New Jersey Rangers | 37 | Oscar Scott | 2020 | Point Pleasant Borough | Sea Bright | NJ | USA | RHP |
| New Jersey Rangers | 1 | Teddy Sharkey | 2020 | Wall | Wall | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Northern Valley Coyotes | 33 | Brandon Siegenthaler | 2019 | Pascack Hills | Montvale | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Midville Dodgers 2019's | 59 | Justin Sisterna | 2019 | Monsignor McClancy Memorial | Woodside | NY | USA | 2B |
| Gallagher Team Mizuno | 18 | Bryant Skurbe | 2020 | Monroe Twp | Monroe Township | NJ | USA | OF |
| Stars and Strikes | 12 | Kolten Smith | 2019 | Millville Area | Millville | PA | USA | OF |
| Sachem Warriors | 2 | Michael Smith | 2020 | Shoreham-Wading River (Shoreham, NY) | Wading River | NY | USA | 3B |
| PS2 Academy Crusaders | 2 | Ryan Sommer | 2019 | Wayne Hills | Wayne | NJ | USA | RHP |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 24 | Gustavo Sosa | 2019 | Tottenville | Staten Island | NY | USA | C |
| Oil City Bandits | 11 | Tommy Srisuro | 2019 | Chaminade | Garden City South | NY | USA | OF |
| Sachem Warriors | 99 | Joseph Stefanelli | 2020 | Sachem East (Farmingville, NY) | Holbrook | NY | USA | SS |
| Sachem Warriors | 19 | Nicholas Stelling | 2020 | Sachem East (Farmingville, NY) | Holtsville | NY | USA | OF |
| Jersey Seminoles | 20 | Thomas Sullivan | 2019 | Northern Highlands Reg H | Allendale | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Long Island Tigers 2019 | 22 | Justin Terrero | 2018 | James Monroe | Bronx | NY | USA | RHP |
| Stars and Strikes | 28 | Justin Thivierge | 2019 | Central Columbia (Bloomsburg, PA) | Mifflinville | PA | USA | SS |
| Elite Baseball Training | 15 | Will Tibbals | 2019 | NYC Lab HS-Collaborative Studies | New York | NY | USA | 3B |
| Long Island Tigers 2019 | 12 | Miguel Toribio | 2019 | James Monroe | Bronx | NY | USA | OF |
| GS Surge Team Akadema Prospects | 14 | Matt Turner | 2019 | Tenafly | Tenafly | NJ | USA | LHP |
| Team Citius Elite | 8 | Xavier Valentin | 2020 | Eastside | Paterson | NJ | USA | OF |
| Wladyka Baseball | 7 | Joey Valentine | 2019 | St. Mary's High School | Clifton | NJ | USA | C |
| North Jersey Bandits | 3 | Joel Valera | 2019 | International | Paterson | NJ | USA | OF |
| Long Island Tigers 2019 | 30 | Angel Ventura | 2019 | James Monroe | New York | NY | USA | RHP |
| Zoned Redhawks Elite | 27 | Gregory Verano | 2019 | Bridgewater-Raritan | Raritan | NJ | USA | OF |
| RIchmond County Nationals | 16 | Kevin Walters | 2019 | Susan E Wagner | Staten Island | NY | USA | OF |
| NJ Yankees | 35 | Eric Wernicki | 2020 | Rutherford | Rutherford | NJ | USA | RHP |
| NJ Yankees | 6 | Scott West | 2019 | De Paul Catholic | Lincoln Park | NJ | USA | OF |
| New Jersey Nationals | 2 | Ray Williams | 2019 | Cedar Grove | Cedar Grove | NJ | USA | 2B |
| Gallagher Team Mizuno | 18 | Kyle Yih | 2019 | Millburn | Short Hills | NJ | USA | RHP |
| Team SSK Crush | 13 | Zaes Zabala | 2019 | Iona Preparatory | Throgs Neck | NY | USA | SS |
| Wladyka Baseball | 4 | Anthony Zamloot | 2019 | Rutherford | Verona | NJ | USA | OF |
| Sachem Warriors | 18 | Zachary Zoufaly | 2020 | Sachem North (Lake Ronkonkoma, NY) | Holbrook | NY | USA | RHP |