2,075 MLB PLAYERS | 14,476 MLB DRAFT SELECTIONS
Create Account
Sign in Create Account
Draft  | State Preview  | 5/29/2011

State Preview: Wisconsin

Patrick Ebert     

In the weeks leading up to the draft, Perfect Game will be providing a detailed overview of each state in the U.S., including the District of Columbia, as well as Canada and Puerto Rico. These overviews will list the state's strengths, weaknesses and the players with the best tools, as well as providing mini-scouting reports on all Group 1 and 2 players.

Wisconsin State-by-State List

Wisconsin Overview:
Competitive Division III Schools Help Define the State's Baseball Success

Wisconsin has no prospects this year that are projected to factor into the first 10 rounds of the draft. Consequently, most of the focus has been on the success of individual teams, notably a fierce rivalry that continues to grow between two state Division III powers.

Wisconsin-Stevens Point and Wisconsin-Whitewater have consistently assembled the most competitive programs in recent years, and the two teams squared off in the semi-finals of the Midwest Regional, with a berth in the NCAA Division III World Series on the line.

Whitewater knocked off Stevens Point, the regular season champion in the Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference, earning its fourth appearance in eight years in the D-III World Series, played annually in Grand Chute, Wis.

Two other Wisconsin colleges, Carthage and Ripon, also qualified for post-season play at the Division III level, and participated in the Central Regional. Carthage fell one game short, or else a second Wisconsin team would have been in the field at the national tournament.

Madison College, formerly known as Madison Area Technical College, also enjoyed its share of success this season, and advanced to the National Junior College Athletic Association Division II World Series. It’s the second consecutive year that the school achieved that feat.

The state's only Division I school, meanwhile, Wisconsin-Milwaukee, advanced to the Horizon League tournament as a No. 3 seed, but never seriously threatened to win the event, unlike a year ago when the Panthers won the conference crown, securing a berth in the NCAA tournament.

Despite success among some of the state’s more prominent college teams, few Wisconsin players elevated their games enough to become factors in the draft.

Wisconsin-Stevens Point outfielder Cody Koback and Madison College righthander Joel Effertz are two of the state's notable prospects, but both are more likely to be selected in the middle rounds.

Koback had a big 2011 season as both an outfielder and starting pitcher, hitting .424 with eight homers, while stealing 16 bases. On the mound, he went 6-1, 3.26 ERA. His future is as a hitter, and he responded nicely this season after playing in only nine games a year ago because of an elbow injury. He doesn't have a standout tool, but is a solid athlete across the board.

Righthander Joel Effertz, a Wisconsin high-school product who played his freshman year in college at Arizona, picked up where Tyler Jones (now at Louisiana State) left off a year ago at Madison Tech. As the team’s staff ace, Effertz propelled the Wolfpack into the D-II World Series by striking out 18, a career best, in the deciding game of the regionals. On the season, he is 7-4, 3.13.

Other notable performers at the college level who stand an outside chance of being drafted include Whitewater's Jeff Donovan, who excelled both at the plate (.390, 21 doubles, eight home runs) and on the mound (10-0, 3.38). The 6-foot-5, 210-pound lefthanded hitter also led the school's football program to a Division III championship in football in 2009 as the team's starting quarterback.

Wisconsin-Milwaukee righthander Chad Pierce, another former quarterback, was recently named the Horizon League pitcher of the year. He was 6-3, 3.07 entering the conference tournament.

At the high-school level, Wilmot Union High's Brendon Hayden may be the best prospect the state has to offer. With his projectable 6-foot-5, 200-pound frame, scouts are more interested in Hayden’s live arm than his bat. His fastball has touched the low-90s, and there is room for more velocity as he continues to mature, but he may need to be convinced that his future is brighter as a pitcher to gain the experience necessary to improve.

A pair of righthanded pitchers, Marquette High School's Nolan Peterson and Oshkosh West's Tyler Willman, round out the high-school players given the best shot of being drafted in the middle rounds. A converted catcher, Peterson has shown improved arm strength and was recently up to 90 at Perfect Game's Pre-Draft Showcase. Willman screams projectability with his tall, lanky build, and he also has flirted with the 90-mph mark.

Two Wisconsin natives who should cause a stir in the 2012 draft are Jacksonville University prospects Adam Brett Walker, a first baseman, and Dan Gulbransen, an outfielder. They project to go in the early rounds, with Walker a candidate for the first round. Bradford High outfielder Nathan Mikolas, the state’s top-ranked high-school junior, could also sneak into the top 10 rounds on the strength of his powerful lefthanded swing.

Wisconsin in a Nutshell:

STRENGTH:
NCAA Division III teams.
WEAKNESS: High-end prospects.
OVERALL RATING (1-to-5 scale): 1.

BEST COLLEGE TEAM:
Wisconsin-Whitewater (NCAA Division III).
BEST JUNIOR-COLLEGE TEAM: Madison College.
BEST HIGH SCHOOL TEAM: Sun Prairie.

BEST OUT-OF-STATE PROSPECT, Wisconsin Connection:
Tyler Jones, rhp, Louisiana State University (attended junior college in Madison; high school in Milwaukee).
TOP 2012 PROSPECT: Nathan Mikolas, of, Bradford HS, Kenosha.
TOP 2013 PROSPECT: Josh Uhen, rhp, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.

HIGHEST DRAFT PICKS
Draft History: Kevin Brandt, of, Nekoosa HS (1979, Twins/1st round, 11th pick).
2006 Draft: Anthony Butler, lhp, Oak Creek HS (Mariners/3rd round).
2007 Draft: Jordan Zimmermann, rhp, U. of Wisconsin-Stevens Point (Nationals/2nd round).
2008 Draft: Adam Frost, ss, St. Norbert’s College (Tigers/21st round).
2009 Draft: Kevin James, lhp, Whitefish Bay HS, Milwaukee (Rays/9th round).
2010 Draft: Tyler Jones, rhp, Madison Tech (White Sox/21st round).

TOP PROSPECTS, GROUPS ONE and TWO

NONE