Not a member yet?
Subscribe Now!

Summer Collegiate : : Rankings
New York Collegiate League: Top 25 Prospects, 2010
Published: Wednesday, September 08, 2010

In Association with League Managers and Scouts
Official League Website:
Year League Established: 1978.
States Represented in League: New York.
Level of Competition (1-to-4 Scale, 1 being highest): 3.
No. of Teams in League: 14 (14 in 2009).
Regular-Season Champion / best overall record (tie): Amsterdam Mohawks, Elmira Pioneers.
Post-Season Champion: Amsterdam Mohawks.
Teams, PG CrossChecker Summer 30/Final Ranking: No. 13 Amsterdam Mohawks.
No. 1 Prospect, 2009 (per PG CrossChecker): Braden Kapteyn, rhp/1b, Amsterdam Mohawks (Kentucky, played in Cape Cod League in 2010).
First 2009 Player Selected, 2010 Draft: Mel Rojas Jr., of, Amsterdam Mohawks (Wabash Valley, Ill., JC/Pirates, 3rd round).
Player of the Year: Tyler Fisher, of, Allegany County Nitros.
Pitcher of the Year: Kyle Hunter, lhp, Amsterdam Mohawks.
Top Prospect (as selected by league): Mel Rojas Jr., of, Amsterdam Mohawks.
BATTING LEADERS (League games only)
Batting Average: Jason Simone, of, Mohawk Valley Diamonddawgs (.372).
Slugging Percentage: Tyler Fisher, of, Allegany County Nitros (.577).
On-Base Average: Vincent Mejia, ss, Glens Falls Golden Eagles (.460).
Home Runs: Cody Kulp, of, Amsterdam Mohawks; Jordan Stouffer, 1b/3b, Albany Dutchmen (8).
RBIs: Jon Schwind, ss/3b, Amsterdam Mohawks (39).
Stolen Bases: Justin Fahy, of, Alfred Thunder (20).
PITCHING LEADERS (League games only)
Wins: Several tied at 5.
ERA: Kyle Hunter, lhp, Amsterdam Mohawks (0.68).
Saves: John Colella, rhp, Elmira Pioneers (13).
Strikeouts: Clay Murphy, rhp, Glens Falls Golden Eagles (58).
Best Athlete: Mel Rojas Jr., of, Amsterdam Mohawks.
Best Hitter: Vincent Mejia, 3b/2b, Glens Falls Golden Eagles.
Best Power: Matt Conway, 1b, Amsterdam Mohawks.
Fastest Base Runner: Brady Wilson, 2b, Watertown Wizards.
Best Defensive Player: Alex Todd, ss, Cooperstown Hawkeyes.
Best Velocity: Shae Summers, rhp, Watertown Wizards.
Best Breaking Ball: Dan Zlotnick, lhp, Amsterdam Mohawks.
Best Command: Kyle Hunter, lhp, Amsterdam Mohawks.
1. MEL ROJAS JR., of, Amsterdam Mohawks (SIGNED/Pirates)
Top ’09 prospect made 24-game cameo before signing with Pirates; same tools/athleticism evident, but didn’t perform as well
2. CODY KULP, of, Amsterdam Mohawks (Shippensburg, Pa./JR in 2011)
Still needs to prove he can play at high level, but has impressive frame/tools; led league in HR, runs well, solid defender/arm in RF
3. JON SCHWIND, 3b/ss, Amsterdam Mohawks (Marist/JR)
Best player on league title team; hit in 3-hole (.292-4-39), 6.6 speed, steady defender on left side; + versatile, may end up at 2B/CF
4. DAN ZLOTNICK, lhp/of, Amsterdam Mohawks (Marist/SO)
Went 4-0, 1.47 record (46 IP/43 SO), utilizing 3 pitches, all for strikes: 89-91 FB, ++ CU, CH; herky-jerky delivery adds to deception
5. KYLE HUNTER, lhp, Amsterdam Mohawks (Dartmouth/SO)
5-0, 0.68 record only added to unbeaten streak, hasn’t lost since a HS freshman; FB at 86-90, but excels with ++ CH, ++ command
6. SHAE SIMMONS, rhp, Watertown Wizards (Southeast Missouri State/SO)
Limited upside in small frame, but lively arm in closer role; dominant vs. wood with 88-92 FB, + SL; went 2-0, 0.61, 5 SV, .106 OBA
7. VINCENT MEJIA, 3b/2b, Glens Falls Golden Eagles (Texas-Pan American/JR)
Solid season at plate (.329-4-34, 36 BB), squared up balls consistently; lacks speed, out of position in MIF, but found home at 3B
8. TAYLOR LEWIS, of, Amsterdam Mohawks (Maine/JR)
Top hitter (.319-1-14) on league’s top team; has big-league frame (6-1, 215), solid LH power, 6.6 speed but needs work on defense
9. JOHN COLELLA, rhp, Elmira Pioneers (Holy Cross/SO)
Made huge headway on summer as closer; FB at 91-92, focused on CU as second pitch; produced 0.00 ERA, 13 SV, 23 IP/37 SO
10. RYAN FERGUSON, c, Elmira Pioneers (Temple/SR)
Most pro ready player in Elmira lineup; solid LH bat (.333-1-29), good power to oppo field; + arm, actions a little stiff, + leader skills
11. ALEX TODD, ss, Cooperstown Hawkeyes (Sonoma State, Calif./SR)
Best defensive SS in league; lean, rangy, smooth, ++ hands, but arm may push him to 2B; hit .295-3-27, drove balls hard to gaps
12. KYLE SHAW, lhp, Geneva Red Wings (Toledo/JR)
One of few LHP in league with + velo; FB reached 91-92 with tailing action, SL/CH showed flashes; needs more confidence in stuff
13. TOM MURPHY, c, Oneonta Outlaws (Buffalo/SO)
Caught eye of scouts with 3-run HR over scoreboard in league ASG; strong frame, + arm strength, needs to polish catching skills
14. MATT CONWAY, 1b/lhp, Amsterdam Mohawks (Wake Forest/SO)
Should have ++ power once he fills out 6-7 frame, shortens long swing; solid around bag; hit .275-3-24, broken wrist ended season
15. ANDREW FOUSHEE, rhp, Elmira Pioneers (Presbyterian/JR)
One of few arms who could command 3 pitches, but lacks power FB; went 3-0, 1.31 (7 BB/39 SO), left early with shoulder tendinitis
16. LUKE MAILE, c, Amsterdam Mohawks (Kentucky/SO)
Lot of upside, but used as No. 2 C by Mohawks; solid defender, + arm strength, power potential, but needs to refine hitting approach
17. BRADY WILSON, 2b, Watertown Wizards (West Virginia/SO)
Makes things happen with 6.4 speed; electric out of box, but needs to become better base runner; improving skills at plate, in field
18. MATT BOULTER, ss, Webster Yankees (Southern New Hampshire/SO)
Ex-MLB SS Greg Gagne was his HS coach, so has + instincts/actions in field; LH bat, hit .331, gap power, + hands to add power
19. JUSTIN VAN GROUW, rhp, Amsterdam Mohawks (Wake Forest/SO)
Still growing into 6-7 frame, and summer impacted by tender elbow, inconsistency; has lots of refinement, but flashed 92 FB, + SL
20. SEAN BOUTHILETTE, rhp, Amsterdam Mohawks (Campbellsville, Ky./JR)
Ex-Kentucky arm transferring to NAIA school; went 5-1, 2.62, highly competitive with 88-92 FB, power breaking ball, workable CH
21. DEREK ZIELINSKI, rhp, Amsterdam Mohawks (LeMoyne/SO)
Just 14 months off TJ surgery, brought back slowly in relief (0.68 ERA in 13 IP); flashed low-90s FB, + CH, needs time to refine stuff
22. MIKE MERCURIO, ss, Glens Falls Golden Eagles (High Point/SO)
Everyday SS as High Point FR; struggled adapting to wood, but bat came on; solid defender, ++ arm, lack of speed hinders range
23. RYAN KEMP, rhp/of, Mohawk Valley Diamonddawgs (St. Joseph’s/JR)
Two-way player, wants to be OF but needs to focus on pitching to realize potential; FB at 89-91, shows signs of + SL in closer role
24. KYLE RICHARDSON, of, Mohawk Valley Diamonddawgs (St. John’s/JR)
Need to overlook 5-7 frame and focus on ++ speed, defensive skills; threw 11 scoreless IP, so arm plays; surprising juice at plate
25. MATT COLANTONIO, c, Amsterdam Mohawks (Brown/SR)
Made favorable impression in all areas, especially baseball IQ; bat (.311-0-7), quick arm are pro tools; + eye at plate (34 BB/90 AB)
Recent Related Articles
Alaska League prospect reports
Live-armed Texas A&M righthanded pitcher Corbin Martin stood out this summer in the Alaska Baseball League as we provide deta... READ 
Coastal Plain prospect reports
Garrett Davila enjoyed a brief tuneup in the Coastal Plain League before signing with the Royals as their fourth-round pick a... READ 
Cal Ripken Lg. prospect reports
Stuart Fairchild carried a successful freshman year into the summer on his way to being named the Cal Ripken League's top pro... READ 
Most Viewed Related Articles
Summer Collegiate All-Americans
With the conclusion of the 2015 summer collegiate baseball season PG has assembled the annual All-America teams, which includ... READ 
Summer Collegiate Top Prospects
Perfect Game once again will provide detailed league-by-league lists and reports from across the nation detailing the top sum... READ 
Hamptons League top prospects
LIU Post righthanded pitcher Dan Jagiello stood out in the Hamptons Collegiate Baseball League this summer as we list the lea... READ